Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

The Jailer's Plan for Azeroth: an Unlikely but Incredibly Awesome Theory

Recommended Posts


So, the expansion started with Sylvanas breaking the veil between Azeroth and the Shadowlands, after a long campaign of helping and working for the Jailer. But what is Azeroth's importance in this whole Jailer-Eternal Ones-First Ones story? This theory not only explains that, but also manages to wrap up and connect Shadowlands' story to Legion's, and much further back - all the way to Warcraft 3. The theory is somewhat unlikely to happen, and is a little out there, but it would be one of the more awesome WoW moments ever if it did.

I've been wanting to write this one for a long time, ever since I read BreHealz original idea for the Jailer's plan for Azeroth a few months ago - but now seems like a pretty good time to go for it, as we're about to find out the fate of Sylvanas (and maybe more) when the Sanctum of Domination arrives today. The article will have some spoilers for later 9.1 story events, including the final part of the new raid so beware.

The Jailer's Overall Plan So Far

For now, all we know is that big chained baldy is gathering up the Covenant sigils, which are powerful items created by the First Ones and given to the Covenant leaders/Eternal Ones. What exactly he plans to do with them is anyone's guess - the most direct/easiest theory is that he's simply trying to break free using that power. But that certainly isn't all of it, as he wanted the sigils before he was imprisoned too, and we actually see him pop up in Oribos during the final Sanctum of Domination fight.

So ok, he wants to unmake/remake death and possibly all of existence, as Syvanas so nicely monologued to Anduin about. But what does any/all of this have to do with Azeroth?

How and Why Is Azeroth Involved?

This one also has a relatively simple explanation, albeit a flimsy one - the Jailer wanted souls and chose Azeroth either at random or because of some greater connection with the Shadowlands we don't yet understand. It all started back in Warcraft 3, with Arthas and the planted Frostmourne, as that was the Jailer's original plan for... souls? We know he got the designs from the Runecrafter's memories, and there's a very indicative line in that cinematic that makes this new theory at least somewhat likely.

"Your grandest design... to claim the final prize. The secret the First Ones tried to hide."

Now this could still all be interpreted as the Jailer's plan for gathering souls via Frostmourne and the Helm of Domination through the Lich King... but that just seems low-level to me, at least in these cosmic times. It is a good enough reason for sure, escape would be quite the priority after thousands/millions of years in the Maw. But could there be more to it?

Ok, Stop Stalling, What Is This Fancy New Theory?

Azeroth has been the focal point of all of WoW and has gathered a LOT of attention from most of the cosmic forces, from the Void Lords trying to create a Void God out of the planet's Soul, to the Legion trying to destroy it to stop that from happening, the Naaru showing up all over the place and so on and so forth. Well, what if the Jailer is after the same thing? After all, his heralds were yelling "Death comes for the soul of this world" throughout the pre-patch.


That's right. BreHealz' theory is that the Jailer was after Azeroth's Soul all along, but in a very different way. Everything we've seen so far in the Shadowlands, in Legion, in Warcraft 3 has all been setup for this. The Jailer is going to make a Mourneblade out of Sargeras' sword and will take control of Azeroth.

I'll just let that awesomeness sit for a bit.


I can already see the full cinematic, as the Jailer's chains reach through from the Shadowlands with the Covenant sigils' power, hitting Sargeras' blade and slowly starting to turn it, leading into the final raid of the expansion. Perhaps we even get to fight Azeroth itself? Sounds like a pretty good finish for a 9.x patch, ahead of 10.0 and whatever revamp that may bring.

As for his ultimate plans once he has done that, well, we don't really care do we? We are Azeroth's protectors and we didn't let Sargeras blow it all up, we didn't let the Old Gods and the Void Lords corrupt it, so we're sure not going to stand by as the Jailer does it. Maybe he'll use the power to make Death the prime power, or unmake the universe, maybe he'll go kill the First Ones (if they're alive), or maybe he's just lonely and wants a companion - really after he enslaves our planet it's all going to hell anyway. Part of the reason this theory is so awesome to me, perhaps too awesome to actually implement, is because it legitimately all makes sense. For now the story is going in a VERY generic "get the 5 mcguffins created by the ancient ones and use them to win/destroy everything/remake everything". But this move by the Jailer actually makes him much more formidable, as it is his planning and finding ways around his restrictions that are his power.

So how did it all work then? Well as we know/will soon find out in the rest of 9.1, the dreadlords were working for Denathrius all along and, well, the Sire is working for/with the Jailer. They set up everything - Frostmourne, the Lich King, even the Legion itself as they corrupted Sargeras by showing him the Void and what it was doing to World Souls. So why would all that preparation be set up "JUST" to get a bunch of souls into the Maw and then use that power? Surely any other planet could have worked too? But we know Azeroth, the World Soul, is special and incredibly powerful. Now maybe it's that specialness that makes it a good connection and soul-ferrying-bridge to the Shadowlands and that's that, but that's just a weaker plot device to me. Also, Anduin may have been important for more than just his power with the Light. He is an Azerothian who is very defiant and would not succumb to the Jailer's domination via Mourneblade quite so easily. After all, Arthas and Bolvar were a failure and defied the Jailer's will for a long time, so he needed to prefect the process if he was going to try it on a World Soul.

Why the Theory Is So Awesome

Aside from the general wow factor of a planet-sized Mourneblade and a World Soul becoming one with Death... ok that really is enough on its own isn't it? Perhaps a little too grandiose for some, but we've really crossed that bridge already, might as well go all-out. But there's certainly more, as this theory connects pretty much everything. And many players might not like the fact that the Jailer has been inserted into the very core of the Warcraft lore from the start, but that's already a done deal, regardless of whether this theory is true or not.

We have a thematic link, with Arthas' corruption mirroring Azeroth's impending one. We have the irony that it's Sylvanas that brings about her own world's doom, and the fact that the Banshee only is the way she is because of Arthas, who was what he was because of the Jailer in turn (this one works in all other theories as well). We have the First Ones hiding the Mourneblade schematics away because it was simply too powerful and could take over a World Soul. The Runecarver succumbing and letting the great secret slip, setting all of the plot from Warcraft 3 onward in motion. The connection with Legion, seemingly the last thread of the Burning Legion's storyline that will now become relevant again. The story actually mattering and having a genuine, visible in-game arc and meaning, not just an inserted "this was what happened all along, you just didn't know it" link between multiple expansions. Frankly, there's even more I could list, but this surely is enough to warrant the "awesome" tag. But is all of that enough? Did Blizzard think of any of this? Will we get this truly epic (in the genuine and not overused and annoying meaning of the word) conclusion to the expansion?

Probably not.

I mentioned in the start this was a long shot of a theory, as it seems far more likely it's the simple get-power-from-ancient-items-destroy world plot (albeit with a pretty great intro with the souls coming in from Azeroth). A lot of the things I talk about above would still apply to this plot as well and enrich it, but it just doesn't have the wow (and WoW) factor of the Sargmourne theory. We still might see Blizzard pull this one off, however, and I for one am EXTREMELY hopeful that we get at least something close to this, or perhaps even better.

So, that's about it. I could go on about the many small details that make it make even more (or less) sense and why I love it so much, but let's not go overboard. We should know some more soon enough, although it's entirely possible that the ending of Sanctum of Domination doesn't progress the story further than the "Jailer gets all the sigils, uh-oh" cliffhanger. I'd say it's a 50-50 shot whether we actually find out what the actual ultimate plan is (other than unmake everything), so this theory could still be possible long after 9.1!

What do you think of it all? Too much? Did I get too hyped and grandiose about it all? Either way, here's the original post that inspired this article and huge thanks to BreHealz for the inspiration and, well, the theory itself!

  • Like 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

It would be badass to play this thing out. And I think the Jailer has said his plans were set in motion so very long ago and every bit is so very carefully planned. So I have to wonder: how in the world are we going to stop him? Mere mortals against an eternal one with a plan older than time. What is it that his 20/20 foresight didn't foresee?

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

You hit some good points and it was an entertaining read, but I just want to recall that Ion Hazzikostas hinted at a time lapse after the Shadowlands expansion. To me, that sounds like we'll be completing the full expansion within the Shadowlands, though I guess there could be another major patch, 9.2, that could have us returning to a newer Azeroth. Seems like too much content for a single patch, so either your theory is wrong or it plays out in the next expansion.


Just for reference:



Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan
      We're looking at the final Mythic+ Tier List of the Shadowlands expansion.
      Dragonflight will be released in two days' time with completely new dungeons, and we thought now would be a good time to look at the final Mythic+ Tier List of Shadowlands.
      The following post is based on statistics provided by Subcreation, a website that gathers various Mythic+ data from live servers. Please note that the tier list is biased toward the top end because it only looks at the top 100 keys per dungeon per affix and ignores keys below +16 and untimed runs.
      As a result, the data presented in this article will always be different from the Mythic Tier Lists maintained by Petko.
      Data Reliability
      The data used in the post comes from Subcreation, a site maintained by Alcaras. Subcreation provides statistical analysis of Mythic+ dungeons, raids, and PvP in Shadowlands, and the data is provided via the Warcraft Logs API and Raider.io. If you'd like to support Subcreation, you can check out their Patreon.
      How the Data is Calculated
      The site looks at the top 100 keys per dungeon per affix across all regions and examines their raider.io scores. For each dungeon and specialization, the site takes the lower bound of a 95% confidence interval of the top 100 runs for each specialization. The site then averages these lower bounds, one per dungeon, to get an overall average lower bound for each spec, which is finally used to create the tier list.
      The site takes the lower bounds of the 95% confidence interval calculated and then clusters them into 6 buckets using the Ckmeans algorithm. You can find more information by reading the site's FAQ.
      Tanks, Healers, Melee, and Ranged are all on the same scale. They're just shown separately for easier comparison across roles.
      Mythic+ Tier List for Dragonflight Pre-Patch Phase 2 Week 2
      The specs are ranked based on their lb_ci which stands for the lower bound of a 95% confidence interval. If a certain tier is missing, it's not occupied by any specialization.
      The following tier list is for this week's affixes: Tyrannical, Raging, Volcanic, and Shrouded.
      Tank Tier List
      Based on 3,223 runs, ranging in difficulty from +16 to +32. 
      S-Tier: Blood Death Knight (190.47) C-Tier: Vengeance Demon Hunter (160.01) Protection Warrior (159.29) Brewmaster Monk (157.53) D-Tier: Protection Paladin (156.63) Guardian Druid (149.62)
      Healer Tier List
      Based on 3,222 runs, ranging in difficulty from +16 to +32. 
      S-Tier: Holy Priest (190.43) C-Tier: Preservation Evoker (161.21) Restoration Shaman (160.49) D-Tier: Holy Paladin (154.30) Restoration Druid (154.23) Discipline Priest (154.05) F-Tier: Mistweaver Monk (144.36)
      Melee DPS Tier List
      Based on 2,753 runs, ranging in difficulty from +16 to +32. 
      S-Tier: Survival Hunter (189.09) A-Tier: Outlaw Rogue (178.24) B-Tier: Windwalker Monk (165.67) Fury Warrior (165.18)  C-Tier: Unholy Death Knight (159.61)  D-Tier: Havoc Demon Hunter (156.44) Enhancement Shaman (155.99) Feral Druid (154.51)  Retribution Paladin (154.07) Frost Death Knight (152.56) Arms Warrior (150.22) F-Tier: Assassination Rogue (79.21) Subtlety Rogue (38.51)
      Ranged DPS Tier List
      Based on 3,082 runs, ranging in difficulty from +16 to +32. 
      A-Tier: Destruction Warlock (182.81) Fire Mage (177.46) B-Tier: Demonology Warlock (168.03) Beast Mastery Hunter (164.29) C-Tier: Affliction Warlock (161.28) Balance Druid (159.79) Shadow Priest (159.42) D-Tier: Elemental Shaman (156.47) Devastation Evoker (156.15) Arcane Mage (155.73) F-Tier: Frost Mage (144.79) Marksmanship Hunter (135.56)
    • By Starym
      The pre-patch period always brings plenty of bugs with it, but it seems the dignity of Worgen has suffered in particular this time around, as their gear sets collection screen isn't looking so hot. There's more than a couple of bugs happening here, related to the Worgen's dual nature, but all of them are equally horrifying and hilarious.
      Ok, so I lied about ALL of them looking both horrifying and hilarious, as this next one definitely leans in to one of those a lot more than the other...
      And finally, while this one is neither Worgen nor gear set-related, I had to add it because, well, I mean I had to, right?
    • By Starym
      The duos are at it again as HeroicSolo and Durendil are 2-manning all sorts of content in the Dragonflight pre-patch! Today we have three Castle Nathria bosses and Vigilant Guardian from the Sepulcher on Normal mode, as well as a +15 in time Tazavesh run!
      Let's start with the +15, with the Vengeance DH and Beast Mastery Hunter managing to get Streets of Wonder done with 9 minutes to spare!
      Then we have the raids, as they take on the early bosses in Nathria and the Sepulcher, with some added commentary below the videos as well:
      Pretty hard fight both in terms of survival and DPS. The hardest mechanics were:
      1) Pneumathic Impact was very painful at 4+ stacks, so I used Last Resort and Feed the Demon talents, aswell as Aegis trinket to survive 4+ stacks. @DurendilLeHunt had used engineery CR to ressurect me on p2 after Pneumathic Impact oneshot, so I could tank the whole phase.
      2) Fated barrier affix – since we're only 2 players, and one of them is not guardian druid (*hehe*), it was very hard part too. So I used The Hunt, Unnatural Malice and Soul Furnace talents to squeeze maximum burst damage into barriers. I've even used Fiery Brand a couple times not as defensive CD, but as offensive CD to zerg barrier ASAP.
      3) Phase 3 was very painful for @DurendilLeHunt , aswell as Exposed Core cast on P1. So I've used Darkness + Pitch Black talents to help him to survive that damage.
      4) Bringing orbs to the gates on P1 was high prio task just to avoid additional tons of adds and start P2 as fast as we can. And running with orb (when we had a whole crowd of adds + active emitter) wasn't trivial for 2 players situation, so I've used both charges of Infernal Strike to bring orbs ASAP.
      Huntsman Altimore was very hard challenge because of +100% damage stacking buff on boss and also we had to kill spirits properly.
      Xy'mox was pretty hard, just long fight with some survival and movement challenge. Kiting ghosts multiple times per fight as tank was very fun ?
      @DurendilLeHunt 's surviving and engineering CR usage skills are incredible ?
    • By Stan
      The Professions overhaul in Dragonflight introduced multiple secondary crafting and gathering stats, but what exactly do they mean and why are they relevant? Find out more about deftness, inspiration, multicraft, resourcefulness, finesse, and more, in our latest post.
      Secondary Crafting Stats
      Crafting Speed
      The stat increases your crafting speed by x%. Ideal for those who create tons of items to sell them in the Auction House. Inspiration
      You craft items at various quality in Dragonflight and Inspiration increases your chance to become inspired and craft an item at a higher quality than your current crafting skill would allow. For those with maxed out crafting skill, the crafted item will have better stats. Multicraft
      Increases your chance to craft additional items by a percentage. When you craft an item, you will have an x% chance to create an additional copy of that item. This only works for stackable items. Resourcefulness
      Decreases material costs of an item by a percentage. Every item has fixed crafting requirements and Resourcefulness will decrease the amount of reagents by x%. Secondary Gathering Stats
      Gathering stats will only affect Herbalism, Mining, and Skinning.
      Increases gathering speed by x%, which means you will mine/collect herbs/skin faster. Finesse
      Gives you a x% chance to find additional herbs/ore/leather. Perception
      Increases your chance to find rare herbs/ores/leather by a x%.
    • By Stan
      Here's a valuable tip for all Transmog collectors! Don't forget to change the vendor filter from your class to "All" to see weapons hidden from your character.
      By default, the gear vendors filter shows you only gear for your class. However, some weapons remain hidden even when your class can equip them. Therefore, it's important to change the filter options to "All."
      One item example is Galerider Shank dagger from the pre-patch event gear vendors, which is hidden from cloth casters by default because it has Agility. However, cloth casters can equip daggers and thus collect the appearance.
      Another example is the Stormbender Saber Intellect sword which cannot be seen by Death Knights, Hunters, Rogues, and Warriors, but changing the vendor filter to "All" lets them buy it.
      The tip has been brought up by Reddit user acctg.

  • Create New...