Jump to content
FORUMS
Starym

US Federal Trade Commission "Likely to File Antitrust Lawsuit" to Block Microsoft Acquisition of Activision Blizzard

Recommended Posts

69466-activision-blizzard-q3-2022-financ
 

Here's some potentially bad news for the sale of Activision Blizzard to Microsoft, as Politico is reporting that it is likely the US FTC will be filing a lawsuit to stop the acquisition - based on three sources "familiar with the matter". A lawsuit could postpone the deal's timing and even endanger it altogether, regardless of its result.

The acquisition deal has seen a lot of pressure and antitrust probes coming from many sides (including several other countries' regulating bodies and watchdog organizations), as it could constitute an unfair boost for Microsoft's side. The most vocal voice against the sale is Microsoft's chief console competitor, Sony, who argues that the sale would open the door to making many Activision Blizzard games (mostly focusing on Call of Duty) exclusive to Microsoft platforms. This, Sony argues, would significantly disadvantage Sony platforms and leave consumers with less choices for gaming.

A lawsuit challenging the deal is not guaranteed, and the FTC’s four commissioners have yet to vote out a complaint or meet with lawyers for the companies, two of the people said. However, the FTC staff reviewing the deal are skeptical of the companies’ arguments, those people said.

The investigation remains ongoing, but much of the heavy lifting is completed, including depositions of Microsoft chief executive Satya Nadella and Activision head Bobby Kotick, the people with knowledge of the investigation said. If the agency does move ahead with a case, it could come as soon as next month, said the people, all of whom were granted anonymity to discuss a confidential matter.

- Politico's Josh Sisco

Well known gaming industry journalist Jason Schreier also weighed in on the story as well:

You can read the full Politico article here, as it goes in to detail about both Microsoft and Sony's arguments so far, as well as Google and Epic's involvement.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

A lawsuit challenging the deal is not guaranteed, and the FTC’s four commissioners have yet to vote out a complaint or meet with lawyers for the companies

In other words, nothing has happened or is confirmed to be happening. This is 100% speculation. Sony's argument is simply "Microsoft could make certain very popular titles exclusive to their systems". That doesn't create an unfair advantage, it is just a continuation of the ongoing battle of consoles. Additionally, Call of Duty is the key issue here, not the entire library of games from Activision Blizzard, which are mostly PC-based. The most likely outcome is a court challenge for appearances but that will end with a court deciding there is no legitimate argument for anti-trust.

In the end, this is Sony trying to delay the inevitable so they might profit from the CoD franchise as much as they can before it gets pulled (if it does at all seeing as there is a huge player-base for CoD on the PS platform). Realistically, it doesn't make good business sense for MS to pull the franchise (or any for that matter) from any non-MS platform as it is just lost dollars and alienated players.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I find it kinda hilarious that Sony who has a ton of console exclusives are complaining about Microsoft getting more console exclusives. Either they get rid of that concept entirely or surely it's fair game for everybody?

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In the end, it all depends on how much MS is willing to spend when they bride the FTC to look the other way with anything that could prevent the deal going forward.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if sony is so afraid of loosing cod they should offer to buy it. you can just buy the game you dont need to buy whole actiblizz if you are only concerned about cod

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Nakzul said:

I find it kinda hilarious that Sony who has a ton of console exclusives are complaining about Microsoft getting more console exclusives. Either they get rid of that concept entirely or surely it's fair game for everybody?

I don't think Playstation would agree with that as they're hypocrites. If exclusives didn't exist Playstation would suffer a lot more than Xbox as there is no other reason other than having friends on the platform to buy one. The price and capabilities are in xbox's favour, gamepass outvalues anything Playstation has to offer, Xbox has a growing 'play anywhere' capability with PC, Playstation has none of this. Even Discord have partnered with Xbox and wont be integrating with Playstation until MARCH/AUGUST 2023

Edited by Cham79

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, rakonga said:

In a field with 15 quadrillion companies churning out games, where is the monopoly? this spectable is inane.

Then you don't know what monopoly means. It's never good when most top franchises are held by same four companies while indie devs are bought up quickly when they get bigger, thus no other independent big publisher or developer can ever arise.

Anyway, I wonder if anything will come out of it. It seemed unlikely that anything could stop this deal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, Cham79 said:

I don't think Playstation would agree with that as they're hypocrites. If exclusives didn't exist Playstation would suffer a lot more than Xbox as there is no other reason other than having friends on the platform to buy one. The price and capabilities are in xbox's favour, gamepass outvalues anything Playstation has to offer, Xbox has a growing 'play anywhere' capability with PC, Playstation has none of this. Even Discord have partnered with Xbox and wont be integrating with Playstation until MARCH/AUGUST 2023

They really are though. Sony has been THE no.1 platform exclusive advocate for years, and even now that they're putting stuff on the PC (literally only in the past year or so) they still do massively timed exclusives. All the things you listed are unrelated to the conversation, you're basically saying "but exclusivity is Sony's only weapon, so they aren't hypocrites when they don't want others to use that same weapon".

Personally I don't want any exclusives at all and I hope if the buyout goes through Playstation keeps all Acti-Blizz games, but Sony has been a giant hypocrite about this - basically shitting their pants over losing CoD - and you'd better believe they'd have done the SAME thing and bought Acti Blizz if they could/the price was right, and then CoD would be 100000% exclusive to Playstation.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, Starym said:

They really are though. Sony has been THE no.1 platform exclusive advocate for years, and even now that they're putting stuff on the PC (literally only in the past year or so) they still do massively timed exclusives. All the things you listed are unrelated to the conversation, you're basically saying "but exclusivity is Sony's only weapon, so they aren't hypocrites when they don't want others to use that same weapon".

Personally I don't want any exclusives at all and I hope if the buyout goes through Playstation keeps all Acti-Blizz games, but Sony has been a giant hypocrite about this - basically shitting their pants over losing CoD - and you'd better believe they'd have done the SAME thing and bought Acti Blizz if they could/the price was right, and then CoD would be 100000% exclusive to Playstation.

I agree with everything you said. Just wanna add that bringing games to PC has no impact on the console war between Playstation and Xbox. Usually people with multiple platforms will have a gaming PC and then one or both of the consoles meanwhile console players generally only have one of the consoles.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 hours ago, Starym said:

They really are though. Sony has been THE no.1 platform exclusive advocate for years, and even now that they're putting stuff on the PC (literally only in the past year or so) they still do massively timed exclusives. All the things you listed are unrelated to the conversation, you're basically saying "but exclusivity is Sony's only weapon, so they aren't hypocrites when they don't want others to use that same weapon".

Personally I don't want any exclusives at all and I hope if the buyout goes through Playstation keeps all Acti-Blizz games, but Sony has been a giant hypocrite about this - basically shitting their pants over losing CoD - and you'd better believe they'd have done the SAME thing and bought Acti Blizz if they could/the price was right, and then CoD would be 100000% exclusive to Playstation.

Quote

you're basically saying "but exclusivity is Sony's only weapon, so they aren't hypocrites when they don't want others to use that same weapon".

I am saying Sony aren't hypocrites? Bro read literally the first sentence I wrote at least 💀

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Cham79 said:

I am saying Sony aren't hypocrites? Bro read literally the first sentence I wrote at least 💀

"I don't think Playstation would agree with that as they're hypocrites." I read that as you thinking that as well/ you presenting their case because you agree, not sure why you'd argue it otherwise.

Also maybe don't go all "bro l2read" when your post isn't quite as clear-cut as you think. I may have read it wrong but there is room for interpretation there, and if I misinterpreted you I apologize. But to me your post still sounds like it's defending Sony, despite the "they wouldn't call themselves" angle.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Staff
      Gamescom is back in August this year, and Blizzard have announced they will be present at the Xbox booth! 
      The event starts on August 21st and runs until the 25th, with War Within, the next WoW expansion, releasing a day after that (or right in the middle of the show on the 23rd for those with early access), so we might get some exciting news on it at the show. Then there's Vessel of Hatred, the new Diablo 4 expansion, as we should get some new info on it as well, with its October 8th release date also looming. The press release also mentions Diablo Immortal and Overwatch 2 will be involved.
      Xbox also announced this year they will have their biggest booth at the event yet, with the Activision Blizzard merger certainly helping with that! 
      And here's the full press release.
      gamescom
      Blizzard Entertainment® is thrilled to confirm their presence at this year’s gamescom, returning to Cologne in celebration of two of their hottest launches of 2024: World of Warcraft®: The War Within™ and Diablo IV®: Vessel of Hatred™.

      This year’s show promises to bring even more excitement, as Blizzard Entertainment will have a robust footprint alongside other Xbox Game Studios in the Xbox booth, as they come together to celebrate upcoming games and connect with the community in Europe and around the world.

      “We are incredibly excited to bring Warcraft, Diablo, and Overwatch to our European community at gamescom,” said Johanna Faries, President of Blizzard Entertainment. “It’s wonderful to be able to travel to Cologne alongside some of our talented developers so that we can gather with players and celebrate the special connections that continue to be forged within our universes together.”
       
      World of Warcraft will be celebrating the launch of The War Within, the first entry in the ambitious Worldsoul Saga. With the global launch set for August 26 - one day after gamescom - it’s the perfect opportunity for the community to celebrate together. Players with the Epic Edition or physical Collector’s Edition of The War Within can play when early access goes live on August 23rd.
       
      Diablo will also be in full force at the event, bringing the world of Sanctuary to gamescom with Diablo IV: Vessel of Hatred and Diablo Immortal.
      
      Overwatch 2 will have a joint stand with Porsche, highlighting their new collaboration featuring a life-sized D.Va statue modeled after the new all-electric Macan and inviting fans to enter a real-life rendition of an iconic Overwatch 2 map.
    • By Staff
      Some great news for Chinese players, as Blizzard have signed a new agreement with NetEase, and players will be returning to their games as early as summer 2024! 
      Most Blizzard games were suspended in January of 2023, with players losing access to their characters and being unable to play World of Warcraft, Hearthstone, Warcraft III: Reforged, Overwatch, the StarCraft series, Diablo III, and Heroes of the Storm, due to an expired licensing agreement. Luckily, a new deal has now been made!
      A lot of WoW players decided to re-roll brand new characters on Taiwanese and Korean servers after the old deal stopped. Their old character data is saved, however, but it will be from back before patch 10.1, so it's going to be a tough decision on how to proceed for them. Perhaps Blizzard can come up with a solution to merge the accounts?
      Here's the full press release:
      (Source)
      BLIZZARD ENTERTAINMENT AND NETEASE RENEW AGREEMENT TO BRING BELOVED TITLES BACK TO CHINA; MICROSOFT GAMING, NETEASE ENTER BROADER COLLABORATION
      Blizzard titles to return to mainland China beginning summer 2024

      Microsoft Gaming and NetEase deepen their relationship, with a strategic partnership based on their shared desire to bring new gaming experiences to players across platforms and markets
      IRVINE, Calif., REDMOND, Wash., AND HANGZHOU, Zhejiang [April 9 PT, April 10 CT] / -- Beloved video game titles from Blizzard Entertainment that captivated millions of players in China will return to the market sequentially, beginning this summer, under a renewed publishing deal Blizzard Entertainment, Microsoft Gaming, and NetEase (NASDAQ: NTES and HKEX: 9999) announced today.
      After continuing discussions over the past year, both Blizzard Entertainment and NetEase are thrilled to align on a path forward to once again support players in mainland China and are proud to reaffirm their commitment to delivering exceptional gaming experiences. 
      The renewed publishing agreement will encompass games Chinese players had access to under the previous agreement: World of Warcraft®, Hearthstone®, and other titles in the Warcraft®, Overwatch®, Diablo®, and StarCraft® universes. Building upon more than 15 years of past collaboration, Blizzard and NetEase are working diligently on relaunch plans, with further details to be shared at a later date.
      Separately, Microsoft Gaming and NetEase have also entered into an agreement to explore bringing new NetEase titles to Xbox consoles and other platforms. 
      “We at Blizzard are thrilled to reestablish our partnership with NetEase and to work together, with deep appreciation for the collaboration between our teams, to deliver legendary gaming experiences to players in China,” said Johanna Faries, President of Blizzard Entertainment. “We are immensely grateful for the passion the Chinese community has shown for Blizzard games throughout the years, and we are focused on bringing our universes back to players with excellence and dedication.” 
      “Celebrating our collaborations, we are thrilled to embark on the next chapter, built on trust and mutual respect, to serve our users in this unique community that we’ve built together.” said William Ding, Chief Executive Officer and Director, NetEase. “Our commitment to providing more exhilarating and creative entertainment experience remains unwavering, and we are excited to see positive synergies fostered to encourage and empower collaborations to bring the joy of gaming to a broad community.” 
      “Blizzard and NetEase have done incredible work to renew our commitment to players – Blizzard’s universes have been part of players’ lives in the region for many years. Returning Blizzard’s legendary games to players in China while exploring ways to bring more new titles to Xbox demonstrates our commitment to bringing more games to more players around the world,” said Phil Spencer, CEO of Microsoft Gaming.
      About Blizzard Entertainment, Inc.
      Best known for iconic video game universes including Warcraft®, Overwatch®, Diablo®, and StarCraft®, Blizzard Entertainment, Inc. (www.blizzard.com), a division of Activision Blizzard, which was acquired by Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT), is a premier developer and publisher of entertainment experiences. Blizzard Entertainment has created some of the industry’s most critically acclaimed and genre-defining games over the last 30 years, with a track record that includes multiple Game of the Year awards. Blizzard Entertainment engages tens of millions of players around the world with titles available on PC via Battle.net®, Xbox, PlayStation, Nintendo Switch, iOS, and Android.
      About Microsoft
      Microsoft (NASDAQ “MSFT” @microsoft) enables digital transformation for the era of an intelligent cloud and an intelligent edge. Its mission is to empower every person and every organization on the planet to achieve more.
      About NetEase, Inc.
      NetEase, Inc. (NASDAQ: NTES and HKEX: 9999, "NetEase") is a leading internet and game services provider centered around premium content. With extensive offerings across its expanding gaming ecosystem, the Company develops and operates some of the most popular and longest running mobile and PC games available in China and globally.
      Powered by one of the largest in-house game R&D teams focused on mobile, PC and console, NetEase creates superior gaming experiences, inspires players, and passionately delivers value for its thriving community worldwide. By infusing play with culture, and education with technology, NetEase transforms gaming into a meaningful vehicle to build a more entertaining and enlightened world.
      Beyond games, NetEase service offerings include its majority-controlled subsidiaries Youdao (NYSE: DAO), an intelligent learning company with industry-leading technology, and Cloud Music (HKEX: 9899), a well-known online music platform featuring a vibrant content community, as well as Yanxuan, NetEase's private label consumer lifestyle brand. For more information, please visit: http://ir.netease.com/.
    • By Staff
      As the Microsoft-Activision deal closes, Bobby Kotick will only stay on as CEO through the end of the year and leave on January 1, 2024.
      Placeholder for tweet 1712818483442987422 Based on the value of his shares, Robert Kotick will leave with around $400 million and if Microsoft/Xbox wants to get rid of Kotick, he will also receive a minimum payout of $250 million.

      Image courtesy of Dexterto.
    • By Staff
      According to WSJ, Bobby Kotick, former CEO of Activision Blizzard, has floated the idea of buying TikTok to potential partners.
      Former Activision Blizzard CEO Bobby Kotick has reportedly shown interest in purchasing TikTok, as legislation in the U.S. threatens to ban or force the sale of the popular app over national security concerns.
      Kotick is said to be seeking partners for the potential acquisition, discussing the opportunity with notable figures including OpenAI CEO Sam Altman. The move comes amid growing scrutiny over TikTok's data privacy practices and its ties to China, with U.S. lawmakers pushing for decisive action.
      You can read the whole news piece over at WSJ.
      Bobby Kotick left his position at Activision Blizzard in December 2023 after Microsoft finalized its purchase of the company. Post-acquisition, he reportedly received over $375 million, as detailed by Forbes.
      Source: WSJ 
    • By Staff
      Blizzard games like World of Warcraft, Hearthstone, and Overwatch 2 might soon make a comeback in China, thanks to Blizzard reportedly teaming up again with NetEase.
      The news comes from Core Esports, which suggests Blizzard's game services could be back by the end of March or the beginning of April.
      After 14 years of partnership, Blizzard and NetEase hit a rough patch in 2022, leading to failed negotiations. Consequently, when the licensing agreement concluded on January 23, 2023, Blizzard's game services were suspended across mainland China.
      For more details, you can check out the article in Chinese or find an English translation by Amy Chen on esports.gg.
×
×
  • Create New...