Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Moozedude

Prot Warrior Moving Forward

4 posts in this topic

Hey all.  Been trying to keep abreast of the changes, harder to do with no beta invite.  I know Estarriol put up some Prot stuff a while back, but there have been many adjustments since then, and I'm concerned.

 

Basically, I'm looking at the fact that, as of today, all of our defensives have been drastically reduced.  Resolve, the new tanking mechanic, only affects healing, which Warriors are legendarily last in as tanks.  Additionally, what healing we did have got nerfed, as Enraged Regen got cut in half and SBar just got nerfed by like 50% or something (if I understand the coefficient).  However, our old standby of SBlk got it's recharge time increased, reducing effective uptime.  To top it all off, a bunch of our personals got reduced in duration or effectiveness.

 

My concern is less the Tank Vs. DPS survivability battle.  I hear damage got tuned in such a way that DPS are still kind of squishy, just not instagib.  And the damage modification with the removal of Vengeance is a huge QoL improvement, no more wet noodle questing.

 

What I'm really worried about is the Tank vs. Tank comparisons.  All the other tanking classes have significant self-heals.  In my raid experience, I can take as little as half the damage my cotank takes in current norms.  However, they have a massive ability to self-heal, and compensate that way for the additional damage taken.  If our usual mitigation is nerfed, plus our healing is nerfed, plus the bonus mechanic for tanking is for our nerfed healing, where does that leave us standing going forward?  I have no doubt that we'll be "viable."  But being last on the list makes it hard to get a raid spot. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You shouldn't be concerned. Every tanking class has had their CD duration nerfed, their active mitigation nerfed, and their baseline healing nerfed. Resolve boosts heals and SBar is counted as a heal. Enraged Regen, Impending Victory, and Blood Craze are also affected by Resolve. When the devs nerfed every class' mitigation, they also changed the way Resolve calculates and actually made SBar stronger. In fact, they made it so incredibly strong that with the last few Mythic tests, there was simply no point in using SBlk because it was possible to spam these massive SBars. I think 50% is a bit excessive, but it's certainly not crippling.

 

SBlk got nerfed, but when you look at the t17 2 set bonus, we'll actually be able to have a much higher uptime on it. Through that set bonus, we get a 25% chance of proccing SBlk for free when using Shield Slam. Then, to make it even better, the 4p set bonus gives each block an extra 30% reduction. Thus, you're essentially getting 100% crit block during SBlk and your actual crit blocks will mitigate 90%. Keep in mind how incredibly powerful those bonuses are when looking at the nerfs to the recharge time and the size nerf on SBar.

 

Even with the nerf, we're still in a spectacularly good position. Before, we were easily the most powerful tanking class. Since then, only paladins have gotten a very small buff with the others staying the same. As of right now, we're still very likely to be on top, we're just not game-breaking anymore. I wouldn't be surprised to see the recharge time get buffed after t17, though.

 

I realize all of these changes look really drastic, but they really even themselves out. Overall, the feel of prot warrior really hasn't changed and we're still very powerful.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I really appreciate you taking the time to put it all into context for someone who can't be there to test it out themselves.  I always value the way you present and define information, Estarriol.  It's why I keep coming here for guidance and conversation.  I greatly look forward to maybe some of those Warrior Chats coming back after we all actually have something to talk about again.  :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Glad I'm able to put things in a way you like! It's kind of funny, I was thinking the other week that if I was not able to get on and play with the changes, I'm pretty sure it'd feel like the end of prot as we know it. Big changes generally look bigger on paper, especially for expansion releases because it is so hard to get that feeling. Especially so since we're switching from Vengeance where Sbar=1.8*Vengeance to a system where SBar is based on a fluctuating percent of AP that is then multiplied by Resolve, which is calculated differently from Vengeance, plus the stat squish. It's really hard to see all of this on paper and know how it works out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Loghaire
      We would be looking for the tank to begin raiding with us Sunday. If you are raid locked until Tuesday please reach out to me still as it isn't a deal-breaker. This is for a core consistent spot within our 5/10M team. 100% attendance is expected during first 2 weeks. Beyond the first 2 weeks, we expect limited to no misses; however, we understand that situations happen. We are also open to recruit DPS, ranged in particular.
      http://www.TeamDeviant.com
      Expectations
      900+ itemized equipped iLevel
      42+ trait points
      knowledge & experience within Heroic/Mythic Nighthold fights
      Server:
      Destromath, Thunderlord, Azgalor & Azshara
      About Us:
      <Deviant> is a progression based 3-day raiding guild formed on July 11th, 2006. We use the EPGP loot system. Members are expected to be on time with consumables and must be capable of receiving constructive criticism. We push our members to improve themselves regardless of being at the top or bottom of the charts and to research boss encounter mechanics before raid time.
      Current Progression:
      5/10 Mythic NH, 7/7 Mythic EN, 2/3 Mythic ToV
      Raid Schedule (Server[CST]):
      Tuesday & Thursday: 10:00PM - 12:30AM
      Sunday: 10:00PM - 12:00AM
      Contact Info:
      If you have any questions, feel free to contact one of our officers directly:
      Enceno#1753 [GM]
      Humanbean#1710
      Monkdom#1900
      Ashayah#1380
    • By Loghaire
      Looking to fill a co-main tank spot for Mythic tonight and beyond. Please contact me ASAP on BNET to discuss.
      http://www.TeamDeviant.com
      Expectations
      900+ itemized equipped iLevel
      40+ trait points
      knowledge & experience within Heroic/Mythic Nighthold fights
      Server:
      Destromath, Thunderlord, Azgalor & Azshara
      About Us:
      <Deviant> is a progression based 3-day raiding guild formed on July 11th, 2006. We use the EPGP loot system. Members are expected to be on time with consumables and must be capable of receiving constructive criticism. We push our members to improve themselves regardless of being at the top or bottom of the charts and to research boss encounter mechanics before raid time.
      Current Progression:
      4/10 Mythic NH, 7/7 Mythic EN, 2/3 Mythic ToV
      Raid Schedule (Server[CST]):
      Tuesday & Thursday: 10:00PM - 12:30AM
      Sunday: 10:00PM - 12:00AM
      Contact Info:
      If you have any questions, feel free to contact one of our officers directly:
      Enceno#1753 [GM]
      Humanbean#1710
      Monkdom#1900
      Ashayah#1380
    • By Rheshi
      <Cheers Bro> is an alliance raiding guild on Stormrage (US). We are recruiting for Nighthold progression.
      Who we are: Raiders from Vanilla and top 40 US raiding experience through current content looking to challenge ourselves with progression and achievements. Our goal is to down all current content on heroic and experience mythic modes before subsequent nerfs, while maintaining a two night a week schedule.
      What we offer:   Experienced, stable leadership with years of raiding experience. Free repairs. We have implemented a Master Crafter system. Raiders can donate materials weekly to supply the bank in return for flasks, potions & food. If you are unable to do so, you may supply your own raiding materials. 
      Loot is RCLootCouncil. Discord for communication. Off-night mythics, Karazhan and PVP is strongly encouraged.
      Raid Times: Friday, Saturday 8:30pm EST - 11:30pm EST
      What we expect: Individuals will come prepared for raids, gemmed & enchanted, having read up on strategies, and contributed to their gearing with mythics and world quests outside of normal raid times. Raiders will run the appropriate addons to assist with raiding such as DBM/Skada/Recount. Racism, sexism, and drama will not be tolerated in any form.
      Raiders should know their class, or where to find the appropriate information. Additionally, they should be open to give as well as receive constructive, positive feedback in an adult raiding environment.
       
      If interested please contact Catlady#1953, or Rheshi#1686
    • By Prodigious
      Vox Viva is a newly created raiding guild hoping to find a group of active and skilled players. We are currently in need for all classes and types so don't be afraid to apply and or whisper me with any questions that you might have regarding our goals. 

      Are you willing to progress and join together with a new raiding roster?

      Only requirements are a iLvl of 895+ and for you to be able to join us during most of our Raids.

      Current raiding times are Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday from 19:30 till 22:30.

      If you're interested in joining or if you're looking for more information, please /w "Prodigious" or "Stérre" On Kazzak.
    • By Sabene
      Very active and friendly guild currently looking to recruit a Guardian Druid/Brewmaster Monk/Blood Deathknight for our core raid group.
      Will consider other tanks, but those three are preferable! 
      We are currently 9/10 H NH (in progress), 3/3 H TOV (AOTC), 10/10 H EN (AOTC)
      We raid Heroic Nighthold Tuesday/Wednesday 5pm-7pm PST ( 8pm-10pm EST). 
      We do alt runs on Saturdays at 5pm-7pm PST (8pm-10pm EST)
      We also run guildies/alts through mythic + keys each week for their weekly max rewards.
      For more information please contact:
      Zayvion (GM) : Zayvion#1576 (B-Tag)
      Twiggerella (CO-GM) : Twiggieemby#1924
      Sabene (Officer) : Gixxer06#1964