Anfauglith

Early analysis on new talents

Sign in to follow this  

4 posts in this topic

Hello guys, 

 

I was hyped about all the announcements about Legion, and I had a bit extra free time so I decided to take a closer look at the new talents. I know it's early and there is not much point in looking at the numbers since the balancing is not complete, but I was curious to see what the rotations might look like in Legion.

 

(link to the talent calculator : http://legion.wowhead.com/talent#Mkx)

 

FROST

 

Tier 1: 

 

  • Sub-Zero: This looks awesome, and sounds like something Frost DKs have been asking for a long time. At a glance, it means that Obliterate will finally benefit from Mastery. But the other 2 choices in this tier are not to be ignored. So, it makes Obliterate do 30% of the damage done as Frost damage. For this consideration, I won't take into account mitigation or extra bonuses from Mastery (I won't go into that much detail). This amounts to  ~300% AP bonus damage as Frost damage on every KM.
  • Icy Talons: With this being moved to talent, it is safe to assume that Frost DKs lost the passive Haste bonus they had. Which means this talent is not to be so easily dismissed. Icy Talons don't stack, so ideally you will FS once every 3 seconds to have 100% uptime. Increased attack speed will net you more attacks, and by extension more chances to proc KM and Rime. Not taking Haste into consideration, most 1H weapons have a 2.60 speed (1 attack per 2.60 s). Over the course of 3 seconds, having 25% increased attack speed won't gain you much, so it is obvious you will need to maintain a solid uptime in order to get the most out of the talent. Taking a window of 10 seconds with 100% uptime on Icy Talons, this will amount to 4 additional auto attacks. These 4 attacks also increase your chances of proccing KM and Rime. The % chance of triggering KM is not available, but I still like the odds that at least 1 out of 4 will make it proc. All this said, Icy Talons looks like a better option if you lack Mastery.
  • Without Remorse: Enables you to go back to the standard DWF rotation.Considering only raw damage gain, making KM affect Frost Strike only will result in 264% AP lower damage than Obliterate (again, not considering mitigation or Mastery). The talent does increase the chances of proccing KM, however, so the real picture is better. Whatever the case may be, I think this talent begins to shine when you start stacking more Mastery. An exact comparison between Sub-Zero and Without Remorse is almost impossible at this stage, however, so I have no idea what might be better as the gear scales.  

 

Tier 2: 

 

  • Frozen Pulse: A straightforward talent, can really shine in AoE intense fights, or even in ST paired with Icy Talons.
  • Biting Winds: Increasing the chance of a Rime proc by 25% is more important than it may look, because Rime now makes HB deal 300% additional damage. Taking a window of 10 KM, roughly 7 should proc Rime, as opposed to 4-5 without the talent. That amounts to ~70% AP per KM proc per target.
  • Soul Asylum: Hungering Runeblade is a new ability, functioning rather similar to the T17 set bonus. It steals fragments of souls every second for 20 seconds, and if you reach 25 souls, the cooldown is reset and it deals 200% AP damage to all nearby enemies.The amount of fragments taken is not mentioned, however. In any case, starting with 5 fragments can make the accumulation process quicker, resulting in more frequent use of the ability and an added 15% damage increase on the explosion. It is hard to evaluate without more details about Hungering Runeblade.
  • Overall: All three are solid AoE options. Icy Talons synergizes well with Biting Winds and Frozen Pulse, so have that in mind when choosing a talent.

 

Rune Regen

 

  • With FS costing 20 RP, I think that both RE and RC are not an appropriate choice for Frost. 1 in 5 chance of proccing them does not seem worthwhile, but these talents cannot be evaluated without sims.

 

The next three rows are focused on survival, and as such, the choice will depend on the encounter.

 

Tier 7

 

  • Glacial Advance: The total number of spikes summoned is not mentioned, but as long as there are at least 2, it should do roughly the same damage as Defile. The fact that it has a lower cooldown than Defile may make it a better choice, but it is too difficult to predict without more data.
  • Defile: Nothing to add here, the talent is not changed from what it is currently.
  • Breath of Sindragosa: With the removal of Frost Presence and Plague Leech, I don't think Frost DKs will have an easy time maintaining BoS in Legion. It still contests heavily with Frost Strike as well, so overall I think BoS will be even worse for Frost than it currently is.
  • Overall: Even though Defile and Glacial Advance both cost a rune, thus possibly decoupling your runes (for more Obliterate/Hungering Runeblade), the talent Runic Longevity can address this issue.

 

UNHOLY

 

Scrapped, because I don't have much more to add to what simpetar already said. Good job, mate xD

 

I'd appreciate your own views regarding the talents, the implications on the rotation and stat weights. Feel free to correct me if I've made a mistake.

Edited by Anfauglith

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Unholy

 

Tier 1:

  • Lil' Stinker looks like a strong option for persistent AoE of stacked 4+ mobs. If the gaseous cloud deals shadow damage, we will probably see some interesting scaling with mastery. On the other hand, it is unlikely that the cloud will stack with itself, so if Timmy uses claw more often than once 6 seconds, overlapping will diminish its usefullness.
  • Shadow Infusion, now this one is interesting. Dark Transformation will have 20 seconds duration and 1 minute CD. That leaves 40 seconds downtime that can be reduced to 0 by merely 5 Death Coils. Some of the Death Coils will surely come from Sudden Doom procs. Looks very powerful for 2-3 targets (transformed ghoul cleaves 3), unless there is some number tweaking.
  • All Will Serve: removal of the CD is an instant cure to one big UH DK problem in PvP. Other than that. it looks decent, doubled fun. Just wondering how the technical aspect will work - when you have 2 pets at once, one is usually considered real pet (with action bar etc.) and the other just guardian (and really dumb). Due to this dumbness of guardians, probably best suited to single target fights (no confusion about what to attack).

Tier 2

  • Pestilent Pustules this talent looks great for setting up great burst. More festering wounds per use of FW mean we will have more runes for (higher damage per rune) SS. Also we get more RP for triggering festering wounds and in return more runes regenerated via regeneration talents. Overall very solid choice.
  • Blighted Runeblade seems good for early game when rune regeration is likely to be slow (due to low ilvl) using 2 runes for average of 2 festering wounds little cumbersome. More data of the actual proc chance and / or PPM would not hurt :)
  • Boiling Rot not exactly sure what to think about this one. The only situation where I could see this talent viable is when we can apply festerding wounds faster than we can trigger them. FS costs 2 runes and hits only 1 target - due to this high cost it is unlikely that we apply FS to multiple targets, unless some sort of insane cleave is required. It is only unlikely that single tick of DnD or Defile is higher on the priority list for triggering festering wound than a single SS cast.

Tier 3

  • RE and RC work in a similar manner as on live. Their chances are reduced to 1% down from 1.5% per RP, which is quite a significant hit. RE will probably get more interesting, because when we have only 1 generic type of runes (instead of BB/UU/FF or Death), we will not have to wait to pair that one with something else and we will ALWAYS be able to use that rune for something rotationally useful.
  • Runic Longevity will probably be the right choice at higher ilvls, where our rotation always tends to get GCD locked. More runes regenerating mean more wiggle room and less danger of resource capping.

Tier 4

  • Obviously very situational, but who doesn´t like stronger AMS from Spellbreaker :) The other two talents look like they wandered here from PvP section.

Tier 5

  • Personal choice: Purgatory will keep your healers on their toes, Death Pact will keep you on your toes and Improved IBF will be active FOREVER! (unless they fix the tooltip)

Tier 6

  • Nothing changed here and still situational While other classes will get access to Death Grip-ish abilities, Mass Grip is still DK specialty.

Tier 7

  • Tortured Spirit very much looks like single target version of Defile: dealing increasingly more damage to one target and completely screwed if the target moves away too fast. Might get interesting if its attack speed scales with haste.
  • Defile - nothing changed.
  • BoS - in addition to live version also restores energy to Timmy. The burst will therefore come from 2 or even 3 sources, making it even more scary.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Blood

 

Tier 1

 

  • Bloodworms - love this talent and think it may be the go to. Overhealing from death pact or BOS turns more or less into DK healing spheres. Great for survival.
  • Feeding Frenzy- a good newer tank talent or passive talent. Basically makes Death strike heal more.
  • Rune Tap: Interesting talent that can give on demand death strikes due to them requiring runic power now. Especially powerful when paired with BOS. However, burning 2 runes could cost other survival issues. More advanced play talent, potentially crazy strong though.

Tier 2

 

  • Rapid Decomposition - makes defile/death and decay heal you. Passive, doesn't sound too bad.
  • Ossuary- interesting talent. Similar to rapid decomp but gives chance for extra bone shields. Good proactive talent
  • Consume Vitality- 25% heal of your missing health every 20 seconds. Very strong reactive talent. This tier will likely be between ossuary and consume depending on fight.

Tier 3

 

  • honestly everything said by previous posts in this thread answers this. longevity probably best later on, empowerment likely better than corruption

 

Tier 4

 

  • Situational but as tank stronger AMS is really the best most useful option

 

Tier 5

 

  • Purgatory in case you derp. Death Pact so you don't derp. Exhume very interesting. Basically you get free boneshield charges on a regular basis. What you do for tier 1 and 2 talents would impact the viability of this. I think paired with consume vitality it would be a very strong reactive proactive combo. However, death pact is such a strong heal. So this tier will be very interesting to test out. Usefulness will depend on other talents. I am a big fan of death pact but with a slew of other self healing options available now, Exhume may pull ahead.

Tier 6:

 

  • Mostly situational but as tank, gorefiends is love gorefiends is life

 

Tier 7:

 

  • SomeInteresting changes
  •  Defile is all but the same.
  • BOS however now triggers your blood shield in addition to healing like death strike. However, it costs runic power so you can't death strike while its up. Plus the heal is less then death strike. The only difference though is it is cheaper then death strike 15 runic power vs 40. so for 30 runic power you get the same heal as a death strike and save 10 more runic power. Interesting decision to be made. It can play both as an emergency heal or as a big blood shield build up before a huge attack. I believe this will likely take the tier
  • Bonestrike is a decent to moderate heal depending on how many enemies are near by. As it stands it feels very underpowered for single target. It could be good in council fights or aoe but BOS just seems better overall.

 

Blood Tanks looking very good to be honest. Very strong talents and some good talent synergy. I think there are some pretty strong builds. Some good choices between reactive or proactive builds or even hybrid ones. I think the raid encounters will determine what is best at a given time. However, I do like that there is a lot of options now for preactive and reactive mitigation. WoD blood tap just didn't feel that active or strong to me. Blood feels more complete now. Also just a lot of opportunities to build stupid strong blood shields. Terminator tanking will definetly still be DK's strong point. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Bloodworms - love this talent and think it may be the go to. Overhealing from death pact or BOS turns more or less into DK healing spheres. Great for survival.
  • Feeding Frenzy- a good newer tank talent or passive talent. Basically makes Death strike heal more.

Bloodworms look well suited for players new to blood tanking, but in hands of skilled players I can see some serious cheese coming Blood DKs are known for :) Especially when used in tandem with Purgatory - you prepare with tremendous overhealing stored in bloodworms, then soak a mechanics you aren´t supposed to survive, trigger Purgatory and let bloodworms heal you back up. ZOMG nerf Blood DKs :D

 

@Feeding Frenzy: The wording is not very clear on this talent, but I believe it refers to the lvl 78 perk of Death Strike mimicking current Will of Necropolis: when your health drops below 35%, all your RP is consumed by next DS and it will greatly increase its healing. It seems like Feeding Frenzy will further increase this emergency healing by 15% rather than flat bonus to every use of DS. (the tooltip mentions "excess RP")

 

@BoS: BoS is channelled and it ticks every 1 second, while DS triggers GCD. If you have, say 100 RP (capped), you can use 2 DS and then have to do something else to gain more RP, or use BoS for (at least) 6 straight seconds and gain more RP while channelling it to extend it further. It looks like BoS will be a very powerful CD to survive agressive ongoing damage like DoTs or enrage mechanics, more efficient than simple DS spam. Not to mention that its offensive part is noticeable as well (100% AP every second)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By WindowsSeven
      I'm not entirely sure what I am doing wrong that is getting me this result, but I am getting about a 30k dps difference on training dummy when I use a defile, clawing shadows, shadow infusion build than when I use the recommended talents. I left the rest of my talents unchanged and I have yet to see where the dps difference is coming from (arbiter or clawing shadows), but I'm very confused as to how this could happen. Links to armory and mrrobot below.
      https://worldofwarcraft.com/en-us/character/wyrmrest-accord/goragi
      https://www.askmrrobot.com/wow/simulator/report/f3a7a9c5f88e4d10b5cb45224684a073
      Defile damage breakdown, Arbiter damage breakdown
      I felt like I had a harder time keeping my disease up and using coldheart on cooldown (or rather whenever at max stacks) with the arbiter build. Am I missing some key thing or do I just need to git gud? Thanks in advance for any help.
    • By Ser3nity
      Safety not Guaranteed is an English speaking Alliance raiding guild on Emerald Dream. We raid 3 times a week and are mainly focused on mythic raiding.
      Current Progress:
      7/7M, 3/3M, 10/10M, 7/9M ToS, 9/11M Antorus
      Recruitment:
      We are currently recruiting the following classes to progress with us through Antorus:

      Melee DPS: Warrior, Feral, DK
      Ranged DPS: Mage, Priest, Boomkin, Ele Shaman, Hunter
      Our raiding schedule is:
      - Thursday: 20.00 - 23.00 (server time)
      - Monday: 20.00 - 23.00 (server time)
      - Tuesday: 20.00 - 23.00 (server time)
      Apply here: http://safetynotguaranteed.guildlaunch.com/
      Even if we are not actively recruiting your class, we will consider any exceptional applications.
      About us:
      Safety not Guaranteed (SnG) was initially formed on horde side by a small group of friends in early MoP, raiding 10man heroic. Later during the expansion we faction changed to Alliance and expanded our roster to a 20man mythic team, where we cleared SoO mythic as a guild. Many of us have been playing together since as early as WotLK, and have friendships with each other that extend outside the game as well.
      Our goal ever since the guild was formed has been to progress through content at a steady pace, without hardcore hours, while having a good time together. We aim to clear each tier before the next one is released. In WoD we cleared 7/7M, 10/10M, 13/13M when relevant, and have cleared each tier so far in Legion obtaining most mythic cutting edge achievements, and plan to continue doing so.
      What we offer:
      A structured mythic raiding team and raiding times. We start invites 19:45 and begin to clear trash so we can have the first pulls at 20:00 A fair rotation and loot distribution via loot council. We keep spreadsheets! A steady guild with a good community and good guild atmosphere. You may encounter some trolling during your stay. A focused attitude during progression, and relaxed attitude during farm content. We like to chat and have fun, but focus during difficult content. A desire to raid. We often run an extra raid day on the 1st week of a new raid tier. This is 100% optional, but most people are excited to get into a new instance. Additionally we often run some sort of alt raids on fridays (100% optional), and do a lot of mythic+ content within the guild.
      What we want from you:
      High attendance. We expect a minimum of 80% attendance, though most of our raiders have near to 100%. We run a small roster to minimize rotation, and want to be able to rely on you. Commitment. We don't want someone who is looking to join, get geared and then leave. We have a 2-3 week trial period during which we will control gearing while we get to know you. Honesty. If you're having problems within the guild, or have real life issues, we'd like to hear rather than you just disappearing. Talk to us. Be prepared! This means reading up on new fights, having consumables (flask, pots, food, runes), gemming and enchanting properly, and being on time! Communication. We want you to know how to communicate both verbally and in writing. We have a guild Discord we use for our raids and other games! Raiding awareness. We want you to not stand in fire, unless it's required... Progression oriented attitude. Everyone makes mistakes, but learning is part of progression, so we value people who continue to improve over time. Understanding. Sometimes, things don't always go smoothly. We may hit a wall on a specific boss for a while, or you may have to sit for someone else during a progression raid. This is part of mythic raiding. We try to treat everyone fairly, and are open to feedback.
      For more information you can add an officer to chat: Joana#2806, Kitty#2896, Noxxus#2229
      Or visit our website: http://safetynotguaranteed.guildlaunch.com/
    • By Sajakain
      ► Introduction:
      <Hand of Fate> is a group of adults who enjoy raiding on a light schedule and still see content cleared. Details of our raid team and atmosphere can be found below. We're looking for like minded individuals to join us in Antorus and for Battle For Azeroth!
       
      ► The Details:
      Here are some of the direct details you are probably looking for concerning our team:
      Raid Days: Tuesday and Wednesday Raid Time: 9:00 PM - 12:00 AM Eastern Standard Time (EST) Invites: 8:30 PM - 8:45 PM EST Current Progression: 10/10(H), 9/9(H), 11/11(H), 1/11(M)  
      ► What We're Looking For:
      Above all else, we're looking for the person that simply enjoys to raid. We have a couple of different ranks; one that permits the casual raider who can only show up once or twice a month and one that is made for the more dedicated - the "serious" raider, if you will. Regardless of rank, however, we expect you to enjoy raiding and have fun playing the game. More details on the differences between these ranks, and their expectations, can e found on our website.
      As far as specific class needs go, we are looking for the following:
      Holy Paladin Shadow Priest
      ► Mythic+ Dungeons:
      We are also recruiting folks that are interested in farming Mythic+ dungeons in addition to our raiding.
       
      ► Contact Information:
      Below you will find the information you need to get in contact with us should you have any questions or concerns. Additionally, you will find the link to our website so that you can read more about us.
      Thank you for taking the time to read this and we look forward to finding like-minded individuals to take on Legion with us!
      Website: http://www.hof-gaming.net/join
      BattleTag Contacts:
      Sajakain (Guild Master): Sajakain#1683 Hatched (Guild Officer): Hatch#1820 Cerïse (Guild Officer): Satonaka#1280 Kissyfer (Guild Officer): Azilee#1343  
      ► Join Our Discord!:
      Join our Discord server! Please be sure to introduce yourself in the #general channel and let someone know you're interested about the raid team!
      https://discord.gg/3TupWMC
    • By Shled
      <PartyCrashers> Alliance - Silvermoon EU
      https://www.wowprogress.com/guild/eu/silvermoon/PartyCrashers
      De eerste term binnen onze guildnaam is ook onze eerste prioriteit. PARTY! Deze kreet naar nieuw raider bloed staat dan ook onder het motto "Life is a party and everyone is invited". Ook jij bent dus invited! Laten we het echter over één ding duidelijk zijn, want zo hebben we het graag bij <PartyCrashers>... Progressie en genieten van de nieuwste raidcontent is minstens even belangrijk als het feestje!
      Wat kan <PartyCrashers> voor jou betekenen in afwachting van Battle for Azeroth:
      Raiddagen op Dinsdag en Donderdag van 20u00 tot 22u30
      11/11 Antorus HC clears & Achievementruns
      Een ervaren en sociale raidgroep binnen een open-minded en relaxed nederlandstalige omgeving
      Consumables, guild repairs, enchants, gems en vantus runes bij elke raid.
      Alt-raids op off-days, want iedereen verdient purple shinies.
      Een actieve en professioneel ingerichte Discord server (inclusief social channels voor het spelen van andere games).
      Gamers die ook wel eens graag een spelletje Overwatch of PUBG met jou willen spelen.
      Veel shits, gigles en meme's.
      Wat zoeken wij?:
      Raiders in alle geuren, kleuren, vormen en smaken. High priority voor een Tank en verschillende DPS classes (ranged & melee).
      Raiders die hun class & role écht door en door willen meester zijn en hier dan ook actief mee bezig zijn buiten de raiddagen.
      Raiders die openstaan voor constructieve feedback en graag willen groeien! Hiermee bedoelen we niet enkel groeien in iLvl maar ook groeien in skill en teamplay.
      Raiders die graag actief meewerken en meedenken tijdens het raiden.
      Raiders die openstaan voor constructieve feedback.
      Raiders die op raiddagen met hun microfoon in de aanslag mee komen praten op onze Discordserver.
      Spelers met een hoop zin in Battle for Azeroth.
      Spelers met een sociale en vriendschappelijke ingesteldheid.
      Ons verhaal
      <PartyCrashers> bestaat uit een kern raiders die samen doorheen MoP, WoD en Legion steeds de eigen grenzen wist te verleggen! Ook voor BfA is dit het plan. Elke nieuwe raid kan van ons team een Full HC clear tot farm-status verwachten. Zonder een elitist hardcore mentaliteit en een gigantische Epeen trotseren we samen mythic encounters ( zo gingen meest recent 5/9 ToS bosses down als een een natte schotelvod) en trachten we de prestigieuze normal / hc raider achievements te behalen. Yes,... we like mounts :v
      In afwachting tot Battle for Azeroth maakte onze raidgroup de transfer van een dode server naar het bruisende Silvermoon. Aangezien onze groep de enige actieve leden telde binnen een grote NL / BE guild op onze oude server werd besloten om bij de transfer de guild <PartyCrashers> nieuw leven in te blazen!
      Interesse? Super! Voeg een van onderstaande toe op battle.net voor meer info!
      Lucky7#2164 (Recruitment Officer)
      Hoddie#2313 (Guild Master / Raidleader)
      Koyulm#2180 (Raidleader)
      See you in Azeroth!
    • By Valkas
      Hello all! I figured i'd make this thread to get some up to date information on the AOE rotation for unholy.  Currently i'm 935 ilvl, and I run Incstructor's fourth lesson and Soul. (For lack of a better option.) However it is my understanding that these two legendaries make for the strongest aoe rotation. Is this true?

       That is my first question. My second is what is the priority for aoe when running these two. Is it to wait for defile to drop, then festering wound a target a couple times, then Scourge Strike? Or is the priority to just put Wounds on then pop them asap, dropping the defile whenever it's available. Typically I wait for defile before I start building Wounds, but given the soul and the extra talent, i suspect it's better to just aoe without Defile if it's unavailable or perhaps just better to rarely spend runes on defile? Curious as to your thoughts!