L0rinda

Hearthstone: Mike Morhaime Statement on DreamHack Austin Racism

Sign in to follow this  

11 posts in this topic

20813-hearthstone-mike-morhaime-statemen

The large amount of racism, as well as other hate speech, in the live stream chat for DreamHack Austin has prompted Blizzard President, Mike Morhaime, to take action. The nature of the action has not yet been confirmed, but Morhaime has released a statement explaining that they are exploring various avenues to combat this growing problem.


The statment, given to Polygon, begins by expressing his disappointment with the offensive language used. He goes on to explain who is being consulted, and which options are being looked at.

Blizzard Icon Mike Morhaime

To help combat this type of behavior during live events, we've reached out to players, streamers, and moderators, along with partners like Twitch, DreamHack, and others, to get consensus and collaborate on what to do differently moving forward. To that end, we're investigating a pilot program that Twitch has in the works to streamline moderation and combat ban evasion. We're also updating our esports tournament partner policies with a stronger system of checks, balances, and repercussions to provide a better chat experience around our content. (source)

He is also aware, that while this cosmetic change will be very welcome, the underlying issue is something that also needs addressing.

Blizzard Icon Mike Morhaime

This is obviously a larger, societal problem that affects us on many levels," he said. "We can only hope that when instances like this come to light it encourages people to be more thoughtful and positive, and to fully reject mean-spirited commentary, whether within themselves or from their fellow gamers. (source)

It is a real shame that this is a necessary step, but having witnessed that chat first hand, it was inevitable. The anonymity provided by the Internet is powerful enough to allow people's hate speech to run free. Stopping this will not stop the hate, but it will make it a more pleasant experience for all involved if they don't have to know about it.
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is there any video of this? Curious to see how bad it got. Possible solution, a screening of incoming messages by a third party? Maybe even somethimg the streamer can access if it doesn't make the multitasking of playing a good game while chatting with the audience unbearable. You also wouldn't want to take screening too far, lest we lose free speech, however in this case, perhaps the talk should be primarily about the game.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

aren't twitch.tv accounts connected to people's facebook accounts (atleast for playhearthstone chat)

and they still spam chat with racism?

 

not sure about dh austin

Edited by causevha

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is there any video of this? Curious to see how bad it got. Possible solution, a screening of incoming messages by a third party? Maybe even somethimg the streamer can access if it doesn't make the multitasking of playing a good game while chatting with the audience unbearable. You also wouldn't want to take screening too far, lest we lose free speech, however in this case, perhaps the talk should be primarily about the game.

One of his matches can be seen here around 43m in https://www.twitch.tv/dreamhackhs/v/65293353

Not sure if this one was before or after the mods got a handle on it, but will give an example.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/19/2016 at 5:09 AM, Soultwist said:

Is there any video of this? Curious to see how bad it got. Possible solution, a screening of incoming messages by a third party? Maybe even somethimg the streamer can access if it doesn't make the multitasking of playing a good game while chatting with the audience unbearable. You also wouldn't want to take screening too far, lest we lose free speech, however in this case, perhaps the talk should be primarily about the game.

Something like Twitch chat is, in no way, a free speech issue.  It's a private space and the owner of a Twitch channel, and/or Twitch itself, dictates what behavior is acceptible; just like you're entitled to kick someone out of your house for any reason you see fit.  If a Twitch channel wanted to, they could auto-ban everyone who uses words beginning with "D".  Most people would think that's ridiculous and they'd lose a lot of viewers but it would not be infringing anyone's free speech.  Nobody is required to provide anyone else with a platform from which to speak.  

Even apart from this not being a free speech concern in the first place, hate speech is not protected speech.  

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, daisyrawks said:

Even apart from this not being a free speech concern in the first place, hate speech is not protected speech.  

Exactly. Freedom of speech =/= the ability to attack someone verbally without consequence.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sigh... Not what I was trying to say really. At the time of writing my post I also had no context to go on. I will say that while I do not condone hate speech (or hate in general for that matter) I am a little leary of the term "hate speech" because I often see it used in place of "differing opinion."  I also believe that what someone says may indeed have consequences, so no argument there. That being said, I will now go take a look at the video to get a better idea of what happened. Hope this isn't taken the wrong way.

Edit: After viewing the content, I agree. Totally uncalled for and rather childish I might add. Looks like there is always going to be troublemakers. It's a shame people can't behave like adults in an environment meant to be fun for everyone.

Edited by Soultwist
Additional statement to make.
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If the first piece of moderation advice is to "just ignore it", then it's being effectively condoned.  What's needed is a zero tolerance policy: because online abuse, just like offline abuse, should not be allowed to stand unchallenged.  Ultimately, to challenge it, the companies that provide the platforms need to spend money to find solutions.  If they don't, then they're condoning it through inaction, and are morally culpable.  They need to police the popular streamers that help them generate revenue, and ensure that they're playing nice as well.

Why did the organizers of Dreamhack Austin not simply pull the plug on the chat?  At the point where one of their players was being abused in front of his family and friends: somebody in a position of responsibility should have shut it down.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, mimech said:

Why did the organizers of Dreamhack Austin not simply pull the plug on the chat?  At the point where one of their players was being abused in front of his family and friends: somebody in a position of responsibility should have shut it down.  

I think this would be an interesting thing to see happen. The organisers would most likely receive hate no matter what they did.

It also would be interesting to see how many viewers were there for the chat rather than the tournament. There is definitely a group on Twitch that goes out of their way to cause stuff like this, so with a muted chat, would they keep watching? How many were there?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/21/2016 at 10:26 AM, Soultwist said:

 I am a little leary of the term "hate speech" because I often see it used in place of "differing opinion."

To be honest, I'm leery of of comments like this because I find "differing opinion" is often used in place of "name calling and generally being horrible".   Every troll, abuser and harasser ever has made the claim that their targets banned or blocked them just for disagreeing or some other harmless sounding thing.  I'd much rather err on the side of a too liberal definition of "hate speech" than a too narrow one.  I'd rather see a small handful of people unfairly banned from Twitch (they can always make a new account or send someone a PM to plead their case and get unbanned) than entire vast groups of people feeling like all of Twitch is actively hostile to them. 

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The more I research this one, the worse it seems to get.  It's all very well for Blizzard to say they're anti-racism, but there are quite a few examples of them seeming to openly support racism.  Like, they feature the streamer Reynad, both as a presenter at tournaments and as one of the people revealing their Old Gods cards.  And Reynad likes to laugh at racist jokes: you can see this on Youtube if you type "reynad laughing at racist jokes" into Google.  You can catch him on Twitter afterwards complaining about the fact that his text-to-speech racist joke frenzy will have to be discontinued due to complaints from Twitch.  So, he's not sorry then.

My conclusion: Blizzard seem to be supporting racism.  Or, more specifically - they support a streamer who laughs at racist jokes.

Then there's Leeroy Jenkins.  That's a white guy pretending to be a black guy, depicting him as tactically ignorant and then using the stereotypical idea of a love for chicken as the punchline.  So, that's racist.  And that's right there in the game of Hearthstone - and it's even a pretty good card in some face decks, so it's a relatively popular part of their popular game.

My conclusion: Blizzard seem to be supporting racism.  They have it in their game.

So, as they're discussing with people how to deal with it: they should clean their own house first.  Lead the way!

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our Toxin Cards guide.
    • By Zadina

      For the first time, we know exactly where and when the card reveals for the upcoming expansion will happen.
      The reveal season will start off with the livestream on November 20. Then, it's time for the fan sites and streamers to take over.
      The schedule for the reveals during November 21 to November 26 has been unveiled and you can check it out below. We will have a fast pace of 3 to 4 reveals per day!
      Blizzard Entertainment
      We’ve teamed up with the Hearthstone community to bring you a treasure trove of card reveals!
      Tricky traps and dangerous dungeon dwellers lurk behind every twist and turn of Hearthstone’s upcoming expansion. We’ve gathered a party of Hearthstone community members to bring to light all the lavish loot and malicious minions they’ve discovered while venturing deep into the catacombs.
      Check out the days and times below, and click the images to portal directly over to their channels. 
      Week of November 20 The schedule for Week 2 will be posted on Friday November 24 PST!
      (source)
      We will be following closely these card reveals. You should look out for them on our news forum and on our Kobolds & Catacombs hub.
    • By Zadina

      It looks like that, contrary to previous expansions, the Kobolds and Catacombs card reveals will start with a card reveal stream.
      We are used to getting card reveals streams in the end of the revealing period, but now we get one in the beginning (and presumably another one in the end?).
      As it was already known, the card reveals will restart on November 20. The stream, hosted by Game Designer Peter Whalen and Brian Kibler, will begin at 11 a.m. PST or 8:00 p.m. CET of that day. It will be broadcast on the PlayHearthstone Twitch channel and it will be available in several languages.
      Hopefully we'll get a good amount of cards shown; we'd expect to see around 15 cards. As always, Icy Veins will be here to cover this. Don't forget to keep an eye at our Kobolds & Catacombs hub!
    • By Zadina

      We finally have a new brawl this week and it rewards a Kobolds & Catacombs pack.
      In this Tavern Brawl, you just pick a class and you get a random deck.
      Both players get a quest. This quest requires that 7 minions are played by any player. When the quest is completed a Treasure Chest, similar to the one spawned by Marin the Fox, will appear on both sides of the board and the quest counter will be reset.
      If you are the one to play the 7th minion, then an easier-to-break 0/4 Treasure Chest (which can be healed) will appear on your opponent's side. In contrast, a normal 0/8 Treasure Chest will appear on your side of the board and vice versa.
      Be aware that even though the quest states that minions need to be summoned, they actually need to be played. This means that cards like Stand Against Darkness or the minions summoned from cards like Barnes or Murloc Tidehunter do not add to the quest counter.
      This Tavern Brawl combines skill and luck. You have to make critical decisions in choosing whether to push face damage or break the chest and hope for the best. On the other hand, a good Treasure Chest highroll can completely change the game.
      Upon victory in this brawl, you will be awarded with a Kobolds & Catacombs card pack which can be opened when the new expansion releases.
    • By Zadina

      The October 2017 lists were a bit late this time, since the Dual Class Arena rankings had to be accounted for.
      We'll start with the top 20 in Standard and Wild. You can find the entire leaderboard here for the Americas and over here for Europe.
      Standard
      Americas   Europe   1. AlwaysLucky 1. Seiko 2. fertygo 2. hunterace 3. hunterace 3. Kyouma 4. DavidSWu 4. Franky3fois 5. naxoloo 5. Meati 6. Satellite 6. Django 7. Monsanto 7. Ogiez 8. ETC 8. Mandalf 9. Cantelope 9. Atouba 10. Chakki 10. Maur1 11. Artefy 11. Zhym 12. PogChampion 12. onepunch 13. pomolive 13. PRTHNCA 14. faNatic 14. Feike 15. zlsjs 15. Saci 16.
      Rase 16. Jarla 17. Arawn 17. Florindo 18. KingOfType89 18. Twink 19. rask 19. NickChipper 20. aqua 20. Orange Wild
      Americas   Europe   1. Hazer 1. Xaos 2. awedragon 2. sipiwi94 3. JTZ 3. Jorj 4. Wargizmo 4. Norwis 5. Ben 5. Liooo45 6. Bananaramic 6. FlamingSword 7. AZSwim 7. Бурзум 8. TitanX 8. HammerSmith 9. Ice 9. Kohai 10. Jonahrah 10. Lubyllule 11. Elf 11. Doux 12. Hurryupidiot 12. Thorclack 13. WildWolf 13. nikitos569 14. XCrouton 14. Hijodaikan 15. blueblurr 15. Cyan 16.
      drTama 16. Fenomeno 17. sipiwi94 17. myr 18. jin 18. Specialist 19. waxwingslain 19. DonSikaleone 20. Roffle 20. Spingy Arena
      During October, the Dual Class Arena event took place, which lasted two weeks. The rankings below represent the top 20 players in the Americas and in Europe during this event, as well as their average number of wins.
      Americas     Europe     1. Zevron 9.20 1. ШтанУдачи 9.67 2. headshot 9.13 2. not2fast 9.60 3. Rakisuta 9.07 3. Conqueror 9.53 4. KellenAbel 9.00 4. Ventox 9.53 5. Hambo 8.93 5. guDDummit 9.47 6. Cheerous 8.87 6. Razu 9.47 7. Middle 8.87 7. Braid 9.20 8. jedddddd 8.73 8. HUMANATEE 9.13 9. Touchit 8.60 9. 那誰 9.07 10. Deception5 8.60 10. oroff 9.07 11. Cicci 8.53 11. Wijkert 9.07 12. Gebuttersnap 8.53 12. Vezhlivij 9.07 13. Turn1Delver 8.47 13. Dchuck 9.07 14. Dentalcannon 8.47 14. JibJab 9.00 15. Moon 8.47 15. Amandriada 8.93 16. Badonkadonk 8.40 16. HugoBOSS 8.87 17. haoqi 8.40 17. Dexter 8.87 18. dk2 8.40 18. ExoticBm 8.80 19. enslen 8.40 19. fosatheone 8.80 20. Crumpled 8.40 20. Duup 8.80