Zadina

Blue Posts: MMR Debate, Tracer Nerfs, Account Suspensions

Sign in to follow this  

4 posts in this topic

16388-hots-tracer-release-date-and-detai

As the title indicates, there were some blue posts recently about three interesting topics.

The "MMR Hell" topic is quite popular in the Heroes of the Storm subreddit. Nostromia's challenge has heated up the discussions on this matter. BlizzLoesby explained how the system works and admitted it needed improvement. His post makes for an interesting read.

Blizzard LogoBlizzLoesby

+ Show
Hello, everyone!

There's a lot of interesting discussion going on in this thread, and I've been glad to read a lot of it. I'd like to clarify a few points to help you all understand some of what Nostromia is seeing on this account.

When Nostromia started playing seriously with this account, her MMR was in the bottom 0.01% of the Hero League population of Europe. As of this morning, when I started looking into this case, the account's MMR has risen to the 45th percentile. This is a massive improvement given the initial placement for her experiment. However, the Matchmaker has been performing admirably, according to the information it had at the time. Each of Nostromia's matches during her rise has been with and against players of similar MMR and Rank to her account's current rating, with very even win probability predictions. Because each of these matches looks even according to the available data, the Rating Update system will think "This player won in a game I thought was even. We'll increase her rating a small amount, since we were pretty sure she belonged here, and see how it goes with and against slightly better players." Winning and losing streaks are not factored into this update, because streaks of this length and consistency are extremely rare occurences, and honestly only happen when there is an extreme change in quality of play for a single account.

To put it simply, one player consistently beating players in Bronze League means the player should rise, but it does not mean the system should move them immediately to Platinum.

There is also talk of the seeming mismatch between Rank changes and MMR changes, indicated by Nostromia's consistently negative Personal Rank Adjustment which, as we've said before, is intended to push players to keep their MMR and Rank closely in sync.

By design, visible Ranks change more quickly than internal Player Ratings. Going on a winning streak is meant to feel good, and will get a player promoted, many times to a Rank that is a little bit higher than the player's normal skill. The length of Nostromia's winning streak is very much an outlier, which exposes the different update speeds much more visibly than players who stick to one account and slowly improve their skills will see. Once Nostromia reaches a rank with other players of her true skill, she will start winning and losing games at a more even rate. At that point, the two different systems will converge on each other.

I've watched Nostromia's stream for a while today, and it is very clear that her play is not that of someone in the lower half of our player base. We're actively researching ways to learn from players' individual performances, in order to move them to where a player of their skill belongs, more quickly. I can't promise timelines on this, or even that the research will bear fruit. We hope to be able to share news on this soon.

Thanks to everyone in this thread for the discussion and interest! All of your feedback is enormously helpful. We will continue to monitor the health of these systems, and work tirelessly to improve your experience as players.

Stay Tight!

P.S. As a side note, I do want to mention that we don't condone players intentionally losing games to lower their rank, nor do we condone account sharing. Intentionally losing games creates a negative experience for 9 other human beings in the game. Account Sharing is a violation of the Battle.Net End User License Agreement. The best thing players can do for themselves, and for their fellow players, is to play on their own account, work hard to win every competitive game, and treat all other players with respect and kindness.

(source)

The Auriel patch will launch this week and Tracer is going to get hit hard, as you can see from the PTR patch notes. A lot of people felt that these nerfs were too harsh, especially for an average-tier, gimmick hero. Game Designer AZJackson pointed out that Tracer can be extremely frustrating to play against and her current win rates are satisfactory.

Blizzard LogoBlizzAZJackson

+ Show
Hey there Eugenie,

I've seen a lot of debate about our Tracer changes and wanted to shed some light on what our reasoning was behind the upcoming patch.

To start, we're OK with heroes being under 50% at different points of play. There are a fair number of heroes who are under that win rate that are highly contested in either Hero League or Pro Play that would get out of control if we tried to buff them to be "healthy" at 50%. Tassadar, Illidan, and Abathur are some examples of these kinds of heroes. Tracer definitely falls into this category because she has a ton of mobility, is fairly difficult to play, but in the right hands and team compositions can be a nightmare for the enemy team (and incredibly frustrating to play against). Just because a hero is under or above 50% doesn't mean we will never nerf or buff them to make them match that number. I can tell you that Tracer is not a hero that we intend to be good in every team composition, and we don't expect her to perform at the same power level as a hero like Raynor in every game (we expect Raynor to be more consistent).

One of the most common reasons why we would, for example, nerf a hero who is under 50% is that they have a style of play that we don't consider healthy for the game. This was the case with Tracer's Spatial Echo talent. Tracer already walks a fine line in regards to counter-play where there isn't as much with her as many other characters, and Spatial Echo blew that completely out of the water by taking away the possibility of enemy players learning to look for her Recall location and punishing her once she uses her major cooldown. In general, we're pushing for Recall to be a stronger decision for Tracer players, and for her opponents to look for that cooldown as a window of time where she can be heavily punished.

In regards to her other talents, the changes were along the same line of thinking. Bullet Spray and Total Recall were giving Tracer powerful tools that were missing in her base kit (self-healing and wave clear + AoE damage), so we decided to tone them down to make her more streamlined overall.

Looking at her stats, since Gul'dan was released, her win rates look like this:

All Games (Quick Match + Unranked Draft + Hero/Team League): 49.8%

High rank Hero League: 49.3%

Considering she is intended to be more of a niche hero, these numbers are looking really good for her.

We'll be continuing to keep an eye on her, and if she is hit too hard in the upcoming patch, we're more than willing to buff up some other parts of her kit in the future. :)

(source)

Lastly, Blizzard has taken action against players who disrupted matches by going AFK or intentionally dying. Similar measures (targeting cheaters or win-traders) were taken this week in Overwatch and World of Warcraft, as well.

Blizzard LogoSpyrian

+ Show
We’ve just issued a round of account suspensions for players who are frequently reported for AFK/Non-Participation or Intentionally Dying during their matches. This initial wave of suspensions was targeted at a handful of users who have received an extraordinary number of reports over the past 30 days and whose in-game performance data clearly indicates a consistent lack of contribution to their matches. While only a few players have been suspended in each region this time, we anticipate that the number of accounts suspended, or in extreme cases, banned, will increase with future waves as we continue to refine and improve our processes.

Going AFK, refusing to participate, and intentionally dying are behaviors that ruin the experience for everyone else in a match and undermine the spirit of competition that’s essential to Heroes of the Storm. Taking part in such actions will not be tolerated. We encourage you to use the relevant reporting options when you spot players doing these things in your games. (source)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So basically what the system is doing explains MMR Hell! You win games you go high but your mmr only changes a little bit? so that means if you go high enough, your mmr is way lower than what your rank indicates, so you keep losing to stay in the same rank your mmr is. 

She might go up but what Loesby said is that she will lose more games soonish. So we can see her stuck in mmr hell sooner or later. I'm watching her stream right now, she's winning games where her team listens to her, but right now she's getting frustrated because her team is ignoring her pings and hints and they are losing, exactly a problem any skilled player might have. Specially in diamond where players think they are doing the right thing and ignore pings.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just love how Blizzard nerfs heroes with high skill cap into the ground, because "  in the right hands and team compositions [a hero] can be a nightmare for the enemy team". But that's the whole point of having heroes like that in the game! They are very bad if the player is bad, but they are extremely good if the player is good. What's the point of having 50+ heroes in HOTS if no matter how skilled the player is, he/she is always limited by the hero design?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 8/6/2016 at 4:52 PM, Zadina said:

Tracer can be extremely frustrating to play against and her current win rates are satisfactory.

So the Hero is at a satisfactory level, but because people find her annoying to fight she gets nerfed? Classic Blizzard, nothing but a slave to the complaints they get on the forums, whether it's balance or not. The whole point of Tracer is to be a high skill cap annoying dps... she fit that perfectly before. Stop basing changes off what people don't like and start actually balancing your games.

under 50% win rates should never call for a nerf, ideally that would show balance in a character, over dominance such as 53%+ maybe but 49% win rates being worthy of a nerf? Seems like the balance team needs to learn the definition of the word.

Edited by WildNerdAppears

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan
      Deckard, Illidan, and Varian will be on sale next week together with the Crimson Hare and Magic Carpet mounts. Check out the full list of items that will enter the featured item rotation on October 23.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Heroic Deals: October 23 – October 30, 2018
      Our next set of Heroic Deals will begin on Tuesday, October 23! Check out the list of upcoming featured items and Hero discounts below.
      Upcoming Hero Sales
      Deckard— Sale Price: 375 gems Varian — Sale Price: 375 Gems Illidan — Sale Price: 250 Gems The following skins and mounts will be added to the featured item rotation and will become purchasable with gems until this round of Heroic Deals comes to an end:
      Upcoming Featured Skins
      Wastewalker Deckard Skin Pack Expedition Vanndar Muradin Genius Monkey King Samuro Azure Big Top Gazlowe Medic Uther Heavenly Grunty Murky Upcoming Featured Mounts
      Crimson Hare Magic Carpet
    • By Stan
      Blackheart seeks revenge against the Commodore in this week's attack/defend battleground! Everyone starts at level 10, no other talents besides that are available. There's a small chance of all players being the same Hero. Play two games to earn a Loot Chest.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Assist a salty revenge-fueled pirate in his other-worldly quest to destroy the docks, or send him to a watery grave with the aid of some spectral cannonballs. This week’s Heroes Brawl is Blackheart’s Revenge, and no matter which side you take, it’s sure to be an explosive match!

      Rules:
      Choose from one of three randomly selected Heroes before entering the Docks. Be quick about it though, you only have 30 seconds to choose! Everyone will begin the round at level 10 and will be asked to choose a Heroic Ability. No other talents will be available. You will either be placed on the Attacking or Defending team and will be responsible for aiding Blackheart in his quest for revenge, or preventing the destruction of the Docks Attackers will be responsible for preventing Defenders from firing Cannons at Blackheart’s ship Defenders will gather Cannonballs and fire them at Blackheart’s ship via Cannons placed around the Battleground After the first round, teams will switch sides and the displayed health on Blackheart’s Ship will be adjusted to show the amount of Cannonballs the defending team must fire to beat their opponent’s score and win the round. The team to fire the most shots at the enemy ship will be victorious, unless both teams fire zero or the maximum of 5 Cannonballs, which will result in ties. Rewards:
      Complete two matches of the Blackheart's Revenge to earn a Loot Chest! Find out more about the new Heroes Brawl game mode on our Heroes Brawl site; and as always, you can find more information on this week’s Brawl by clicking the Brawl Info button at the bottom of the play screen when preparing to queue for the Brawl game mode.
    • By Stan
      The latest Heroes of the Storm content patch is now live with Mal'Ganis, disabled Haunted Mines, and changes to certain Support abilities to only work on Heroes.
      Patch Highlights
      Mal'Ganis is now live and you can check out our build guide here. The Hero is also available in the talent calculator. The game no longer supports DirectX9 and the 32-bit version of the client. Haunted Mines have been removed from all gameplay modes. Ana's Healing Dart now pierces targets at full Health. Multiple Support abilities have been reworked to only work on Heroes. Blizzard (Source)
      General
      Heroes of the Storm no longer supports DirectX 9 and the 32-bit version of the client. Battlegrounds
      Unranked Battleground Rotation:
      The Battleground Rotation for all Unranked modes has been adjusted to the following: Alterac Pass Battlefield of Eternity Blackheart's Bay Braxis Holdout Cursed Hollow Dragon Shire Garden of Terror Hanamura Temple Infernal Shrines Sky Temple Tomb of the Spider Queen Towers of Doom Volskaya Foundry Warhead Junction Haunted Mines: Haunted Mines has been removed from all gameplay modes. It will still be available to be played in Custom Games. Mercenaries: Sappers can no longer have their charge attack interrupted by a Silence effect. Silencing Sappers will still prevent them from starting to channel this ability New Hero: Mal'Ganis (Warrior)
      Cunning and intelligent, Mal'Ganis was chosen to bring Arthas Menthil into the Lich King's service. After manipulating the prince into purging Stratholme of life, he finally fell to Frostmourne as Arthas's first act as the Lich King's champion... yet a demon does not die so easily.
      Trait
      Vampiric Touch Mal'Ganis heals for 45% of damage dealt to enemy Heroes and 15% of damage dealt to non-Heroes. Basic Abilities
      Fel Claws (Q) Violently slash in the chosen direction, dealing 78 damage to enemies. Reactivate to slash up to 2 more times. The third slash Stuns enemies for 0.75 seconds. Necrotic Embrace (W) Desecrate the air, dealing 119 damage to nearby enemies and gaining 25 Armor for 3 seconds. Night Rush (E) After 0.75 seconds, gain 50% Movement Speed for 2 seconds. While active, Mal'Ganis can move through enemy Heroes and put them to Sleep for 2.5 seconds. Heroic Abilities
      Carrion Swarm (R) After 1 second, disperse into an Invulnerable swarm of bats for 3 seconds, dealing 74 damage per second to enemies. Vampiric Touch heals for 100% of Carrion Swarm's damage to Heroes. Dark Conversion (R) Channel on an enemy Hero for 0.75 seconds, then swap Health percentages with the target over 3 seconds. Design
      Support Heroes
      We've unified certain Support abilities to only work on Heroes (not minions or Mercenaries): Alexstrasza
      Gift of Life (Q) Breath of Life (Q-Dragon Form) Brightwing
      Pixie Dust (E) Li Li Healing Brew (Q) Rehgar
      Healing Totem (Active - Level 4) Earth Shield (W - Level 13) Tyrande
      Light of Elune (Q) Uther
      Holy Light (Q) Heroes
      Support

      Ana
      Abilities
      Healing Dart (Q) Healing Dart will now pierce targets at full Health. Collection
      New Bundles
      The following new bundles are available for a limited time! Mal'Ganis Heroic Bundle Death & Undeath Bundle Meat Wagon Bundle New Announcer
      Mal'Ganis New Mount
      Meat Wagon Northrend Meat Wagon Blackrock Meat Wagon Deathguard Meat Wagon New Skins
      Mal'Ganis Dreadmachine Mal'Ganis Neocarbon Dreadmachine Mal'Ganis Master Deadmachine Mal'Ganis Infernal Mal'Ganis Northrend Mal'Ganis New Portraits, Sprays, and Emojis
      Several new emoji packs and portraits have also been added to the game.  Bug Fixes
      General
      AI Heroes: Fixed multiple cases of AI-controlled Heroes incorrectly using their abilities. Spell Power: Fixed an issue where Spell Power would no longer affect a Hero’s abilities after they died. (For example: Jaina’s Blizzard will now continue to deal bonus damage if she received increased Spell Power but died before the second and third waves.) Statis/Time Stop: Fixed an issue where player created terrain could move Heroes affected by Stasis or Time Stop. Battlegrounds
      Garden of Terror: Fixed an issue where all three Garden Terrors could spawn in a single lane. Minions/Mercenaries: Fixed an issue where Heroes could block the movement of Catapults, preventing them from passing through intact gates. User Interface
      Fixed an issue where a space would appear before the player’s name in a Whisper. Heroes, Abilities, and Talents
      Ana: Fixed an issue where Ana’s Shrike healing was not accurately reflecting her damage done (via Spell Power or her target’s Armor). Chromie: Fixed an issue where Temporal Loop’s return location would appear incorrect if a movement ability was used by the target. Diablo: Fixed an issue where Diablo would not be displaced by knockback and similar effects while casting Overpower. Gall: Fixed an issue where not all cases of Damage Reduction would work on Gall. Gul’dan: Fixed an issue where Darkness Within’s bonus Spell Power would not increase the healing of Drain Life. Kharazim: Can now Radiant Dash to all allied units, including Mercenaries, Creep Tumors, and Toxic Nests. Li-Ming: Fixed an issue where Tal Rasha's Elements would grant bonus damage to Calamity after being twice in a row. Murky: Egg Hunt’s Slime no longer benefits from Slime talents. Sylvanas: Targets of Mind Control will now clear their move orders when affected by the ability. Uther: Fixed an issue where Holy Fire’s damage was affected by Spell Power. Mal'Ganis is now live and it's time to check out our build guide and the official patch notes.
    • By Stan
      Alan Dabiri announced that he's leaving his current position as Game Director for Heroes of the Storm and he's moving on to another project at Blizzard.
      Alan Dabiri has been Game Director ever since Dustin Browder stepped down in December 2016. He thinks the game is in the right hands right now, as developers continue to deliver interesting new Heroes and events. He's transitioning to a new team within the company. We wish him success in all his future endeavors.
      Here's the message he left on the official forums:
      Blizzard (Source)
      In my 20-plus years at Blizzard, I’ve had the privilege of working on many awesome Blizzard games in roles ranging from software engineer to technical director to game director. Across my many roles and games, my experience working on Heroes of the Storm ranks among the best of my development career. I’ve witnessed Heroes’ evolution from a StarCraft II mod to the amazing game you see today. Heroes’ development has been fueled by the shared excitement of our team and all of you in the community, and the game we’ve built together is the game I play almost every night.
      One of the best things about developing Heroes is the fact that this team is not afraid to try new things while always striving to learn and grow. It’s been part of our DNA from the very beginning, and it’s through years of experimentation that we’ve hit our stride both as a development team, and as a game. This is possible because Heroes has an exceptional development team of both Blizzard veterans and fresh faces who are all highly engaged with the game we’re making, and the players we’re making it for.
      It’s in this spirit of trying new things that I want to let everyone know that a few months ago, I accepted an opportunity to transition off my role as Heroes’ game director to heed Blizzard’s call and begin a new adventure elsewhere within the company. The game director has always been one part of the overall leadership team that drives Heroes forward and it’s been a privilege to work among some of the best game developers at every level on the team all the way up to our production director, Kaéo Milker. Leaving a team and game that I love is incredibly difficult, but seeing the steady strength, creativity, and commitment that Kaéo and the design, engineering, and art leadership teams consistently bring to Heroes has given me more than enough confidence to make this decision. I trust that the game is in the very best hands and their work these past few months has only reinforced my belief.
      They’ve released awesome new heroes like Yrel, Whitemane, Mephisto, and now Mal’Ganis, while building on the themed content drops that let the team do fun things that only Heroes can do. They brought the smackdown (plus my favorite mount, the Luchihuahua!) with Nexomania, finally brought an epic slice of Azeroth into the Nexus with the Alterac Pass Battleground, and joined the Raven Lord’s forces with the Fall of King’s Crest. On top of that, the team has also released awesome reworks like Raynor and Brightwing while adding exciting updates like third ban and Team League improvements. With so many awesome content and feature updates, you can see why I believe that the team has brought us the best year of Heroes of the Storm so far.
      And they’re not done yet. Heroes has one of the most passionate and dedicated development teams I’ve had the pleasure of working with, and they have a ton of exciting new content in development. I can’t wait for you all to see what they have in store for the rest of this year and beyond. You can bet that I’ll be right there enjoying it with you as it’s released, too. I’m sure you’ll agree when I say that Heroes is in a great place and I promise that it’s in the hands of the best possible people to continue driving it forward. Kaéo and the Heroes team are people who play almost every night who also happen to get to work on making the game what it is today. With our continued input and support, they’ll keep doing what they do best by making Heroes of the Storm the most awesome game it can possibly be.
      I just want to sign off by saying thank you to all of you. I’ve had an incredible time working on this game and seeing you bring the battlegrounds to life every day. I’m so grateful for the enthusiasm you’ve brought to Heroes and all the changes you’ve encouraged us to make. I know the team deeply appreciates the feedback you share, so please keep it coming—and as always, I’ll see you in the Nexus!
    • By Stan
      Free Hero rotation has been updated for the week of October 16 and features Yrel, Chromie, Chen, and more.
      Free-to-Play Hero Rotation: October 16, 2018
      Malfurion Valla Gazlowe Johanna Thrall Dehaka Lúcio Falstad Li-Ming Alarak Yrel (Slot unlocked at Player Level 5) Tassadar (Slot unlocked at Player Level 10) Chen (Slot unlocked at Player Level 15) Chromie (Slot unlocked at Player Level 20) (Source)