Playing Arms, bottom 25% of dps. I need help, please. (Included armory, logs to help decipher the issue)

8 posts in this topic

Dear Fellow Warriors,

I've been playing arms for quite awhile now, and I've not been doing well in raids. On fights like the Dragons, routinely bottom tier of my group's dps.
On Ursoc though, I was 4th. However, my dps seems too far from what others are able to accomplish. (IE, I'm only doing 212k DPS on Ursoc - Normal)

On the Lesser Sparring Partner, i'm only doing about 150k dps. after two minutes-3 minutes of parsing


To help distill the issues with my rotation and take away most of the mechanics, let's use the gear check boss, Ursoc, since it's relatively immobile.

My Armory: http://us.battle.net/wow/en/character/frostmourne/Darksong/simple

Let's compare two logs. One's mine (ilvl 844 - 212k dps), with someone of similar iLvl (844 368k dps), on the same fight in Normal Ursoc:

My Logs: https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/YDcMvgnAJpPhXyfK#fight=13&type=damage-done&source=56

Comparison Logs: https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/93kqYVwpQv1fA2ag#fight=19&type=damage-done&source=135

Ok, taking out the fact that I don't have a legion pot, and didnt use Pot of the Old War, I seem to be doing very little damage, my MS hits for a lot less, etc.

Taking a look at my damage during Heroic Dragons of Nightmare, is rather depressing. Here I finally managed to buy some flasks, but not to much effect it seems.


Let me explain my rotation:

1. Charge
2. Stack Focused Rage to 3 stacks
3. Battle Cry + Colossus Smash + Avatar,

(During Battle Cry)
Hit CS/MS when it pops up, else FR+Hamstring till 3 points, slam if FR already at 3.

(Once out of Battle Cry)
Continue building FR stacks, hit CS and MS when it comes up (even if FR less than 3)

(Once in Execute Range)
Colossus Smash->Execute ->CS->Exe when available.

PS: One question, since I've been focusing on maximising my mastery, my non-CS/shattered Defenses MS has been pathetic, maybe doing 200k damage with 3 FR stacks. Should i be maximising my CS duration (IE: do NOT hit CS again when there's still a few seconds left on the CS duration?)

Thanks in advance for ANY help at all.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

The other guy has a tighter rotation in all respects:

0.145 CS cast per second vs 0.122 - a difference of 16%
0.145 Slams cast per second vs 0.039  - a difference of 74% (!)
0.209 MS cast per second vs 0.145 - a difference of 31%

The Slam disparity is huge and points to you not spending rage efficiently. This in turn affects Tactician. You don't have advanced logging for your parse so I can't see resource gains/spending but that's gotta be it. Basically, stop cheesing with Hamstring and use Slam.

The rotation difference probably accounts for about half of your 156k dps difference. The other half seems to be:

1. Fight length. 2:04 vs 4:14. Their heroism uptime is a third, yours is a quarter. Same goes for pots and dps buffs. Notice how his Avatar is up with the pre-pot and initial time warp, and then comes up again for the execute phase, as does the pot.

2. Consumables. You have no Satyr neck, you're not using a competitive potion. Old War and Satyr end up doing 10m damage during the fight, which is 20% of what you did in a fight twice as long.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi there Unigolyn,

Thanks for the help and the time you took to read the reports.

So during the Battle Cry, What do you usually do?

I used to make sure i had a 3 FR MS, turn on BC,  and use a macro for FR + Slam, until either CS or MS procced.
However i was told I should just macro FR + Hamstring, in case a CS or MS procced, and I didn't want to waste a GCD on slam.

Now starting to think otherwise. Hamstring of course no longer procs Tactician, but Missing out on Slam damage if CS or MS doesn't proc during the remaining seconds of Battle Cry, seem like such a wasted DPS opportunity, especially when you take into account Blood of Zakajz.



Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

hi, usually top dps wherever i go

playing arms, my opening rotation:

single target: charge, colossus smash>battle cry>spamming MS and WW, got both macroed with Focused rage (#showtooltip Mortal Strike/cast mortal strike /cast focused rage), also spammed hamstring but they changed that today (28.09.16) not proccing tactician.

whenever i get a reset on colossus smash, i use it. You always want to use MS after a CS, or execute depending on the % on the mob youre hitting (because of artifact trait: shattered defenses)

using warbreaker if i dont have CS up, MS coming off CD because i want to get the use of shattered defenses.


aoe rotation: charge>warbreaker>battle cry>bladestorm, after BS i use cleave>whirlwind (with macro for focused rage, MS when i can on targets with CS up.


my armory: http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/ragnaros/Chipman/simple

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for picking up this analysis guys. Inclined to agree with Unigolyn here.

As for your further questions, I'm not sure, but this bump should help find someone that does know, I hope!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

You are making a mistake during Battle Cry.

FR/Hamstring are not on the global cooldown, so you should be spamming that along with Slam, you can do both at the same time, rather than waiting for 3 FR stacks then using slam which is what you are describing.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been reading through a lot of these threads lately.  After the recent hot-fixes, Hamstring obviously no longer procs Tactician. Is it still a good idea to keep it macro'd with Focus Rage and Slam for the soul fact of it not being on the GCD? Or not? If not what's the best macro to spam during Battle Cry? I know Darksong asked the same thing in one of the previous posts, I just wanted to clarify.  Currently during BC if CS isn't up (generally I wait for at least a reset before even using BC) I have a macro for FR, HS as well as Slam which I spam for resets. Sorry if I'm kind of thread-jacking but this will probably help others with a straight forward answer. Thanks in advance. 

  • Like 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Olilis
      ABOUT Adventure
      Recruitment Status:
      NOTE: Raid times are all 8:30-11:30 EST (Server Time)
      Social Raid Team 11/11H (Thursday & Sunday): OPEN
      Weekday Raid Team 1/11M (Tuesday -Wednesday): OPEN TO ALL
      Heroic Team 11/11H (Friday-Saturday): OPEN (930+ iLVL 1 million DPS Required)
      Mythic Team 6/11M (Friday-Saturday): OPEN (Requirements will be discussed with you)
      ♦ DBM
      ♦ ERT
      ♦ WEAK AURAS
      **  DISCORD
      OUR GOAL:
      Our goal is to create/maintain a cohesive, tight-knight, long-term family oriented raid team(s) where everyone has fun. In order to accomplish this, each member must understand that they, as an individual, are a part of the team, and are responsible to the whole group to bring their A game every raid night.

      Experienced Raiders - Many of our players have played since Vanilla/BC and are retired hardcore players who just want to have fun while raiding casually
      Friendly community - We help our guildies whenever possible so as to help with progression. This is to include running mythic+, alt runs, advice on rotations or with enchants/gems.
      Class Knowledge - We are a raid full of competent players that know their class and push themselves to the best of their ability and expect for you to do the same
      We come prepared! Flasks, food, etc.
      Achievement Junkies! We do weekly achieve runs!

      Class Knowledge - We are seeking raiders who know their class' capabilities and limits and seek to push these limits
      Prepared - Someone who is always prepared for a raid (flasks, food, etc)
      Situational awareness - We do not want to have to call out every ability that every boss does every time they cast it.
      Personality - Long story short, if you’re a prissy drama queen who complains about everything (or anything in this case) you will find your time here very short lived. We do not tolerate ragers, beggars or scammers.
      Intellect - You need to be smart, we’re not asking you to calculate the entropy of a black hole, however, we don’t want to have to explain things more than once because it takes away from valuable raid encounters
      Attendance - We require 90% attendance. We understand that things come up in real life and you won’t be able to attend every raid, and we accept that, but if you miss raids because you just can’t commit to our schedule, there are better guilds for you.
      Team Effort - We expect our raiders to be team players who help each other, respect each other, take on challenges and roles suited for their class, and work together towards our raids success

      Humor - Whether in guild chat/vent, there is always something to laugh about
      Understanding - Most of our guild is either in college or working adults with families. We understand real life schedules and family situations. Real Life > Wow.
      Honesty - We will always be up front and to the point from day one. You will receive mature and constructive criticism from our Officers if we believe it will help you to perform better
      If interested please contact me on the forums or on battlenet @ EKLYPSE#11512
    • By DeathWaits
      <Defiance> on Shadowsong/Borean-Tundra, US
      11/11 H - AoTC
      4/11 - Mythic
      Tue/Thur/Sun 630-930 pm PST
      Fri - Optional fun run for alts/friends and family
      Currently accepting exceptional and positive players of any class for the Mythic progression.
      Melee: OPEN -- Desired: Rogue, Ret, DH, Fury, Feral Ranged: OPEN -- Desired: MM Hunter, Boomkin, Ele Sham Healer: OPEN -- Desired: Resto Druid Off-spec FLEX Tanks Defiance is a casual-core or semi hardcore guild that raids and runs Mythic+'s but we always try to find something to do every day of the week while hanging out together in Discord. We have done the top 100 thing in past expansions. We don't call it quits when content gets rough, we review our strat, adjust as needed and get back to it. With that being said, we want to make progress but we are more concerned with just enjoying the game and each other's company.
      We are not interested in the elitists and nobody likes a know it all, just have a positive attitude. We work to build an environment and community that players want to log into everyday and enjoy. Doing so helps prevent burnout so we can enjoy endgame content without all the stress most Mythic raid environments endure.
      Feel free to add our battletags to get in touch with us. We look forward to hearing from you!
      Btag: Deathwaits#1484
      Discord: Deathwaits#1976
      Btag: AaronC#11555
      Discord: Shamy(Aaron)#1760
    • By Pottsy
      Hallo Abenteurer, Couchpotato's, Lerroooy's und Achievementsammler.
      Um nicht nur in den Hauptstädten Werbung zu machen und aktive Member für den Raidkader, Mythics und weiteres suchen, zähle ich erstmal auf was wir aktuell erreicht haben, zukünftig erreichen möchten und was uns wichtig ist.
      Mythic +
      Bei uns sind immer genug Leute am Start, um mit seinen Chars die Weekly Chest abzustauben
      Unsere Raidzeiten liegen auf Mittwoch und Sonntag von 20:00 - 22:30 Uhr, damit auch jeder für sein Berufsleben ausgeschlafen ist.
      Zurzeit haben wir in Antorus HC auf Farmstatus und equippen nach und nach unsere Twinks.
      Für den Mythicraid suchen wir noch engagierte Spieler für unseren Kader, da wir das ganze als feste Gruppe in Angriff nehmen wollen.
      Aktuell suchen wir Mages, Shadows, Eulen und Ele-Shamis für unseren Raidkader.
      Du solltest 945 GS und mind. 75 Traits in der Artefaktwaffe haben (für M+ können GS und Traits natürlich variieren - Twinks sind auch erlaubt und gern gesehen).
      Das Menschliche muss passen. Der beste Tank/DD/Heal bringt uns nichts, wenn er sozial inkompatibel ist.
      Aktivität und Interaktion mit anderen Gildenmembern wird gern gesehen.
      Wenn du 18+ bist, Discord hast und teamfähig bist, kannst du dich gerne auf Blackmoore bei Gringer, Pottzy oder Kraadarok melden und einfach losflüstern; Wir freuen uns von dir zu hören und zu lesen! :)
      Falls du uns da nicht antreffen solltest, adde uns über die BattleTags. Trau dich!
    • By Gywn
      Hello, I'm a friendly neighbor from the guild <Conspiracy Theory>. We are currently looking for raiders for H prog and Casual runs every
      Sat - 8-11 EST, Sun - 7-9:30/10 EST. We are a 9/11 H Guild looking for more members to fill it's ranks.
      We also are forming a secondary raiding team. We are looking for active players who will be on at least once/twice a week.
      Along with forming a Mythic dungeon team to help gear raiders for their retrospective raiding teams.
      We have a very lax community with serious raiders, Jokes and memes are to be had everyday. Conspiracy Theory is a very helpful community between helping newer players learn how to play their classes to running current content.   Server - Dalaran   Contact me via Bnet or Email
      Email "blastzonekid@gmail.com"
      Bnet - "Crazedreaper#1496"   Contact GM via Bnet
      Bnet - "BowTieGuy#11785"
    • By Voodu
      Dragonblight US Monkey Business 1/11 M 11/11/H guild recruiting for mythic Antorus raiders to fill out our ranks.  Need healers and dps, iLvl at least 950, heroic or mythic Antorus raid experience required, please apply at: wowmonkeybusiness.enjin.com or whisper Geegi in game.