Strobes

How Accurate is Simcraft?

3 posts in this topic

EDIT: The characters in question are

Me - http://us.battle.net/wow/en/character/fenris/Cygnius/advanced

Friend - http://us.battle.net/wow/en/character/fenris/teldrali/advanced

-----

Hey, guys. I downloaded simcraft and ran some patchwerk simulations today to help me decide which pieces of gear I want to be wearing, since I have a number of things that seem like they could be viable for my Demonology Warlock The results don't really match what the article here states, but still show Haste on top for single target, and very close to Int for 2 and 3 targets, which seems to at least somewhat match the guide here. I figured this would be good enough for me to determine which gear choices would be the best for me to equip.

However, I was curious and wanted to see what it said for a friend's character, who is a Fire Mage. From my understanding, Crit is always king for Fire Mages, but the results showed the opposite, which is making me question Simcraft as a whole. Am I doing something wrong? Must something more be done than to import your character, select the type of fight you want, which plots you desire, etc.?

Here is a link to the scaling results, labeled for convenience.

 

Edited by Strobes

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

On the whole I've found Simulationcraft to be accurate (as much as I can guess anyhow). It is as only as good as the user though. So it does depend on whether you are using a recent version, make sure it is 7.1.5-02 and the options you select.

You have to understand that the stat weights calculated are based on your current gear set so to me it's no big surprise it actually wants you to get more Intellect (basically a higher item level, well except on jewellery). Your haste value is way ahead of the other secondary stats and Mastery is lower than Crit on multitarget so it seems a decent result overall to me. 

You also do not have the 4 set yet which have some impact. 

I would still use with caution though and if you are going to use those weights rather than long term ones you need to sim frequently to see how they develop. 

Also use BiS Lists as a guide for gearing choices (this does not include dungeon gear): https://notwarlock.github.io/LockOneStopShop/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Treylawny
      <Trust> may be what you're looking for if you enjoy killing internet dragons with a group of like minded players! Currently we are 8/9 Heroic, soon to be stepping into Mythic ToS. We are recruiting to finish rounding out our raid team. <Trust> is located on the [US] Doomhammer/Baelgun pve servers, alliance side! Check us out!
       
      About Us:
      <Trust> is a recently formed guild, founded by a group of long time players that have been raiding together for a couple of years now. Founded out of a desire to continue raiding in a casual-progression manner, we work towards defeating mythic bosses. <Trust> is a raiding guild, first and foremost.
       
      Our Raids:
      <Trust> maintains a progression-oriented 2-day semi-casual raiding team. That's 'semi' as in we expect our team members to always prioritize life first; but not 'casual' as in we take downing bosses less seriously. We strive to maintain a balance of taking our progression raids seriously while having plenty of laughs along the way.
       
      Raid Schedule:
      Tuesday & Thursday: 5p – 8p server (8p – 11p eastern)
      Friday(optional): 5p – 8p server (8p – 11p eastern)
       
      Recruitment:
      <Trust> is looking for full time Resto Druid, Mages, Hunters, and Warlocks for our raid team. We are also open for good people to join as casual players, pvpers, with the option to join farm content or alt raids.
       
      More Info:
      Feel free to reach out to us:
      Recruitment Officer:
      In game - Treylawny
      Battletag - Treylawny#1813
       
      Guild Lead:
      In game – Oleic
      Battletag - Jarg#1591
       
      -OR-
       
      Website and Application: <Trust> (US)Doomhammer/Baelgun
      (The app is quick and painless as its used primarily to get your name to us quickly!)
       
      Discord is our way of communicating during raid; also used for casual chatting!
       
    • By Crudetorrent
      Hi, This is about Ice Veins Demonology 100 talent discussion. I'm greatly confused about this, since I can't see any synergy between Ascendance and Soul Conduit. If anyone could clarify this. I've already thought about it having something to do with summons. But it has to do with DE so yeah. Simply can't see the synergy with theese two together.
      Copied right from the 100 talent discussion from Icy Veins:
       Soul Conduit is the best option for single target and light cleave and should be your go-to for most encounters. This talent is only worthwhile if using  Thal'kiel's Ascendance.
       
    • By Picina
      Hi,

      I try to get better an do more damage with my demonology warlock. 
      Here is my character and a log.
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/qDRzMH1KaPdjApyf#fight=3&type=damage-done&view=timeline&source=27
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/character/eu/antonidas/gouldana
      What are my faults? What can I do better?
      Thank you for your comments and help,
    • By Thistlebloom
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/GKFVvtzTpAZMjXNr
      I have been studying my logs consistently for weeks now and trying to raise my dps. One of the main things I've figured out is that my DE uptime is crappy... However, I have tried my darnedest and can't seem to get it higher. I know i cast it after every demon summon/ summon combo and even downloaded an add on to help me track my demons and their empowerment status. I am at my wits end and NEED some practical advice! Also, if you see anything else that is a major issue please let me know.
    • By krisdamx
      Hi im Lock 882 4 pieces of tier +2 Legendaris  this is my armory
      http://us.battle.net/wow/es/character/drakkari/Yizux/simple
      and this is a log by thrilliax encounter
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/tk1jfRNyva4GgVXd#fight=11&type=damage-done&source=3
      thx for the help :3