Jump to content
FORUMS
Starym

WoW Classic Tank and Healer Rankings/Tier List

Recommended Posts

7TqKjNr.jpg
 

After we took a look at the state of DPS in WoW Classic, or more specifically the pre-raid geared rankings, it's time to go over the tanks and healers as well! As last time, the lists are to determine which class will be the best in a raid environment, with exclusively the best available pre-raid gear and consumables. As always, these tier lists aren't the be all and end all of determining which class is the best for everything, but it's a good indicator of the general power of each.


Definitely check out the full guides (Tank, Healer) , as they delve into the specifics for each class, as well as fully detail the reasons for the rankings and more.

Tanks

  1. Warrior (S-Tier)
  2. Druid (B-Tier)
  3. Paladin (D-Tier)

Healers

  1. Priest (S-Tier)
  2. Shaman (A-Tier)
  3. Paladin (A-Tier)
  4. Druid (B-Tier)
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
  • Confused 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Allseye said:

Dont like these kind of rankings. This just lead people to overrate a class while its not even necessary...

Honestly, I tend to agree. While it is interesting to know how all the classes shape out against each other in a perfect world, it's incredibly important to remember that raiding in WoW Classic is NOT the same as raiding on retail. The raids are far easier, and with 40 people in the raid you can get by with bringing almost anything. Molten Core especially is doable with 20-30 geared players, meaning you could bring anything for those last few spots and it wouldn't matter. 

 

Play what you find enjoyable. If doing the most damage in the game is what you want to do, by all means follow the tier list, but do not be afraid to role an Enhancement Shaman or Feral Druid just because it might not be the best at its role. Some of the best players that I've ever played with have been die hard fans of non-meta specs and loved trying to bring those specs to their absolute maximum potential.

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Borgoff33 said:

more like

Warrior (S-Tier)

Drud (Dont bother)

Paladin (Dont bother)

@Borgoff33

Druid is perfectly fine and quite close to the potential of a warrior. Paladin is not for the faint of heart and requires a great deal of effort in order to make them a possibility. 

Edited by CaperfinWoW

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For those that are curious there are indeed paladin tanks right now that are clearing bosses in MC but not entirely cleared yet.

Shaman Tanks should follow shortly 🙂

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am going to assume this ranking is solely based on simulations. Player skill, communication, and coordination in any group is what wins. <edit> and gear helps 😄

Edited by Regnomed

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Allseye said:

Dont like these kind of rankings. This just lead people to overrate a class while its not even necessary...

Well, we all know how poorly balanced Classic was.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 minutes ago, Valhalen said:

Well, we all know how poorly balanced Classic was.

Dpswise or probably tankwise, yes it was. But well, if you don't so much dps, you bring some utility/buffs. In classic, there is no need to play with meta-classes. There is no ranking-system (beside PvP) where you have to push things in time to get higher gearlvl or more loot. It simply takes a bit more time but it's not even less fun.

People without any knowledge of vanilla read such rankings, go ingame and say "LF protwarrior, mage, warlock, fury warrior / rogue". But's its not retail, it simply doesn't matter at all. You can run with whatever you want. Adjust tactics, help each other and you will clear every dungeon. I dont talk about raid, because with a roster of 40 ppl you simple need a handful "mandatory" ones and fill up whatever you like. It even doesnt matter if you play a clean rotation, it just takes longer.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Honestly giving a B rank to druids is misleading IMO.    You should emphasize that while they're ok for 5-mans, raiding they're going to be chumped hard.    Otherwise people might be tempted into thinking they're viable, just not the best (say the equivalent of a Paladin tank in retail, who struggle at times but can tank any of the bosses; they're just not used by world first guilds).   That is Not the case in classic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Allseye said:

(...) I dont talk about raid, because with a roster of 40 ppl you simple need a handful "mandatory" ones and fill up whatever you like. It even doesnt matter if you play a clean rotation, it just takes longer.

Raiding in Vanilla was pure nightmare. Managing people in 10 man is already stressfull; with 40 you just wanna rip your hairs out of your skull.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Migol said:

Otherwise people might be tempted into thinking they're viable,

bear druid tanks are viable. They become optimal or very close to it a few days after a warrior has tanked ced boss, this is a general rule. Druid tanks just need a small amount of time to gear up to get to the position of where warriors stand. I play as a Shaman Raid Tank so I'm quite familiar with this. By no means is druid tanking easy, which is what I think this list is accounting for. 

Edited by CaperfinWoW

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 9/16/2019 at 9:20 AM, CaperfinWoW said:

@Borgoff33

Druid is perfectly fine and quite close to the potential of a warrior. Paladin is not for the faint of heart and requires a great deal of effort in order to make them a possibility. 

They probably work better than some claim for sure, but you can't say that they are fine without 'in my opinion' following it. EVERYONE says that Warrior is superior both in dps and tanking especially since they scale insanelly well with gear. I'm playing a hunter (for nostalgic reasons) and some say they only need 1 in raids cause it's bad compared to other dps classes. Yet idgaf. I'm there for the experience - when I bother lvling. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
49 minutes ago, Znifler said:

They probably work better than some claim for sure, but you can't say that they are fine without 'in my opinion' following it. EVERYONE says that Warrior is superior both in dps and tanking especially since they scale insanelly well with gear. 

oh no this is not my opinion. Game's been out for 15years this stuff is factually proven by years of data and cross-referencing.

Quote

I'm playing a hunter (for nostalgic reasons) and some say they only need 1 in raids cause it's bad compared to other dps classes. Yet idgaf. I'm there for the experience - when I bother lvling. 

 

Hell, I play a Shaman Tank I triply dgaf what people say is impossible.

Edited by CaperfinWoW
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
53 minutes ago, CaperfinWoW said:

oh no this is not my opinion. Game's been out for 15years this stuff is factually proven by years of data and cross-referencing.

 

Hell, I play a Shaman Tank I triply dgaf what people say is impossible.

You may be right, but I just assumed based on what I've read the last months. And damn, did not know shaman tank was a thing, or you caught me good. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 9/18/2019 at 3:13 AM, Znifler said:

You may be right, but I just assumed based on what I've read the last months. And damn, did not know shaman tank was a thing, or you caught me good. 

People always throw off-meta tanks like the druid under the bus just because it was not conventional during vanilla, despite the mountain of info we have today. The same thing can be said of Shaman Tanking, it has unbelievable potential if you put in the necessary effort.

Edited by CaperfinWoW
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Stan
      Free Character Moves in Europe will be available starting tomorrow from select realms in addition to the free transfers from all PvP servers to Mandokir (EU).
      Click here to check out the recently-announced Free Character Moves for US/Oceanic realms.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Beginning at 01:00 CEST (00:00 GMT) tomorrow (Friday 18th October), we will open the following Free Character Moves for realms in this region:
      FROM TO Ashbringer Bloodfang Ashbringer Dragonfang Ashbringer Earthshaker Ashbringer Judgement Dragon’s Call Heartstriker Dreadmist Bloodfang Dreadmist Dragonfang Dreadmist Earthshaker Dreadmist Judgement Firemaw Bloodfang Firemaw Dragonfang Firemaw Earthshaker Firemaw Judgement Flamegor Вестник Рока (Harbinger of Doom) Flamelash Bloodfang Flamelash Dragonfang Flamelash Earthshaker Flamelash Judgement Gandling Bloodfang Gandling Dragonfang Gandling Earthshaker Gandling Judgement Gehennas Bloodfang Gehennas Dragonfang Gehennas Earthshaker Gehennas Judgement Golemagg Bloodfang Golemagg Dragonfang Golemagg Earthshaker Golemagg Judgement Lucifron Heartstriker Mograine Bloodfang Mograine Dragonfang Mograine Earthshaker Mograine Judgement Noggenfogger Bloodfang Noggenfogger Dragonfang Noggenfogger Earthshaker Noggenfogger Judgement Patchwerk Heartstriker Razorgore Bloodfang Razorgore Dragonfang Razorgore Earthshaker Razorgore Judgement Rhok’delar Вестник Рока (Harbinger of Doom) Shazzrah Bloodfang Shazzrah Dragonfang Shazzrah Earthshaker Shazzrah Judgement Venoxis Heartstriker Wyrmthalak Вестник Рока (Harbinger of Doom) Zandalar Tribe Bloodfang Zandalar Tribe Dragonfang Zandalar Tribe Earthshaker Zandalar Tribe Judgement All of the above are in addition to Free Character Moves available from all PvP realms to the Spanish realm: Mandokir.
      As always, we strongly encourage you to utilize the Free Character Move service as soon as possible. Free Character Moves will be closed without warning for any destination realm that becomes full.
      Thank you!
    • By Starym
      There's a whole lot more free moves coming tomorrow from pretty much all US and OC servers, in addition to the already ongoing moves to Latin American and Brazillian realms. While the transfers start tomorrow, there's no end date listed, however moves will be closed as soon as a target realm reaches high population. With layering being removed completely soon, and already at a bare minimum now, these moves come at a pretty good time.
      October 17 (source)
      Beginning at 11:00 a.m. PDT tomorrow (Thursday, October 17), we will open the following Free Character Moves available for realms in the Americas and Oceania:
      FROM TO Arugal Felstriker Atiesh Azuresong Atiesh Windseeker Benediction Arcanite Reaper Benediction Earthfury Bigglesworth Anathema Bigglesworth Arcanite Reaper Bigglesworth Earthfury Blaumeux Anathema Blaumeux Arcanite Reaper Blaumeux Earthfury Faerlina Arcanite Reaper Faerlina Earthfury Fairbanks Anathema Fairbanks Arcanite Reaper Fairbanks Earthfury Grobbulus Anathema Grobbulus Arcanite Reaper Grobbulus Deviate Delight Herod Arcanite Reaper Herod Earthfury Incendius Arcanite Reaper Incendius Earthfury Kromcrush Arcanite Reaper Kromcrush Earthfury Mankrik Azuresong Mankrik Windseeker Pagle Azuresong Pagle Windseeker Skeram Loatheb Sulfuras Arcanite Reaper Sulfuras Earthfury Whitemane Anathema Whitemane Arcanite Reaper Whitemane Earthfury Yojamba Felstriker All of the above are in addition to Free Character Moves available from all PvP realms to the Latin American and Brazilian realms.
      As always, we strongly encourage you to utilize the Free Character Move service as soon as possible. Free Character Moves will be closed without warning for any destination realm that becomes full.
      Thank you!
    • By Starym
      It seems there was a short-lived bug in Dire Maul North that allowed the buff the guards gave after completing a tribute run to stack! A hotfix has been deployed around 30 minutes ago and that is no longer the case, so if you managed to snag some extra power you've had your fun and it's now fixed!
      Dire Maul Buffs (source)
      A hotfix was applied to all realms 30 minutes ago that squashed that bug. The buffs obtained from the guards in Dire Maul North after completing a tribute run will no longer stack.
      Thank you for your feedback on it!
      You can also check out our DM guides as well as an official preview for the dungeon here.
    • By Starym
      It's been a while since we got word that something weird was happening with the auras in Classic, with several aspects that affect them already resolved. Today we have further progress on that, namely the part where some item enchants were using up slots and thus knocking off helpful buffs like Power Word: Fortitude and the like, as the issue has been partially fixed. There are still some item enchants that require a slot, but that's what it was like in 1.12 as well so it's staying. Check out the full details below:
      October 15 (source)
      With scheduled maintenance earlier today, we applied the following hotfix:
      WoW Classic
      Enchantments on gear should no longer count as helpful auras. They now count as passive auras. There are still some enchantments occupying helpful slots – notably, the Arcanum enchants that will come from Dire Maul and other enchantments that are applied via item rather than via the enchanting profession. This was the case in our 1.12 reference.
      Thank you very much!
    • By Stan
      Dire Maul will be available later today at 10:00 AM PDT // 7:00 PM CEST. Blizzard decided to open the dungeon ahead of Phase 2 which brings World Bosses and the Honor System including PvP Rank Rewards to WoW Classic.
      UPDATE: Our Dire Maul Dungeon Hub is now up! Check it our to learn more about the dungeon!
      Phase 2 will launch later this year, according to the latest interview by Game Director Ion Hazzikostas.
      Blizzard (Source)
      Following up on our announcement from last week, Dire Maul will become available today, October 15, at 10:00am PDT.
×
×
  • Create New...