apparition666

fire VS. frost war

37 posts in this topic

hey guys, look I know there has been plenty of posts on this subject, but I want a final conclusion. optimally played, under the exact same conditions, what would come out on top, fire or frost? because I run frost excellent but I hear fire does more dps. I am currently testing and running fire,I have read and also discussed that if I play it optimally and get good combustions it is top spec for dps as far as mages go currently. but frost to me seems far more consistent with less annoyance of rng. so honestly, which is the best way to go? what would I get more out of? because so far it's all pointing to frost. here is my armoury. http://us.battle.net...parítion/simple I can also post some parses on world of logs if needed. I just really want to know what overall would be better. cheers!

Edited by apparition666

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fire. Just realize it's far more difficult to play optimally. Also the difference at 526 ilvl isn't that big, but it does start to pull away.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At a 525 ilvl Fire has the potential to be approximately 5%-10% better than frost (dependent upon the fight and if played optimally). That margin grows significantly at higher gear levels. However, you can absolutely raid effectively as frost. If you enjoy frost and are more comfortable with it than fire, then stick with frost. Most players will do far better dps with a spec they are comfortable with and enjoy than trying to force a change to a spec that they don't like.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

good day, men

same question

i have

http://eu.battle.net.../Блорн/advanced

choise between fire and current (frost)

as i understand, fire is better after full 522

choise became actual when i tried to join normal (813) guild. mage's class leader told about changing spec into fire

i think now i'll make better dps in frost

help plz

offtop

should i prefer mastery instead of haste after 8025 (haste)?

i've inspected Kuznam and see reforge into mastery

p.s.

here we can find some logs

http://worldoflogs.com/guilds/30625/

thx for future answers)

Edited by MaximMazov

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fire mage stat priority currently is Intellect > 15% Hit > Crit > 5036 Haste > Mastery > Haste

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just restating it because it's the same for your situation.

At a 525 ilvl Fire has the potential to be approximately 5%-10% better than frost (dependent upon the fight and if played optimally). That margin grows significantly at higher gear levels. However, you can absolutely raid effectively as frost. If you enjoy frost and are more comfortable with it than fire, then stick with frost. Most players will do far better dps with a spec they are comfortable with and enjoy than trying to force a change to a spec that they don't like.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Vlad,is the 5036 haste number self or raid buffed?

Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

5036 is the haste rating you will need prior to buffs and that is non-goblin. For goblin's it's 4565 (I think)

With 5036 haste rating + 5% raid buff you will be able to get 24 tick glyphed combustions. This is what all the top fire mages (that I know) are doing currently.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fyz if you replace:

neck gem with a +320 crit

hand enchant with mastery

and reforge:

Chest 329 haste > mastery

Hands 323 mastery > hit

I believe you will be optimized Posted Image

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just curious, does Mr Robot's Optimization for Fire change the rating of Mastery over Haste after you break the 5036 point? I don't think it does but I have no way of checking for sure until I get home from work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It does but you have to click the Edit Weights button, then under Haste Soft Cap you can check Manual and enter 5036. The other option is in that same Haste Soft Cap box, check Smart Picker then click Change Soft Cap (this will open another options box). In that new window uncheck Combustion and check Combustion (Glyphed). Now over to the right you should see a list of breakpoints and you are looking for +4 ticks on Combustion (Glyphed) 5036 (non-goblin). Click on that breakpoint and it will set it on the stat weight for you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Further to the spec discussion, I'm arcane and waiting for better gear to go back to fire 510 currently. I was under the impression arcane was lowest, but checking raid bot (is this reliable) vs world of logs, fire and arcane are close to top and fire WAY down closer to bottom. Iwas going to switch to frost but seems really pointless, unless I'm reading data incorrectly http://www.raidbots.com/dpsbot/Overall_DPS/25H/100/14/60/default/. currently 6/12 tot, and no complaints (so far). Should prob make new thread for this sry, Thanks for any input. Centrian.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The problem with raidbot is, that it only tracks the players... I mean..

Think sensefully, most "skilled mages" went for fire or arcane, because they thought they will be the leading specs for ToT. Many many players followed them, and switched to fire. What I mean is, fire and arcane specs have a higher number of playerbase, than Frost at the moment and most professional players who know how to play a mage optimally play these two specs leaving Frost with the less skilled players. (no offense to anyone)

To be frank, if the world top mages switched to frost, that would be the leading mage spec at the moment...

More frankly, I can easily do the same ammount of DPS as a fire mage on my same item level, depending on the type of the fight.

On the other hand, I have a strong feeling that fire will be by far the best in 5.4 with that amount of crit we will have, unless they get a nerf. Knowing this, I actually started practicing again with fire. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Arcane is the least mobile and really only great for Megaera and Ra-den and It requires 4pc bonus to be competitive and scales well at the top end. Fire has the greatest mobility and best top end for almost every fight.

below ilvl 505 go frost

between 505-525 frost is pretty equal to fire

after 525 go fire or arcane

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Arcane is the least mobile and really only great for Megaera and Ra-den and It requires 4pc bonus to be competitive and scales well at the top end. Fire has the greatest mobility and best top end for almost every fight.

below ilvl 505 go frost

between 505-525 frost is pretty equal to fire

after 525 go fire or arcane

Mehh, too many players are trying to convince me to go fire.. :D

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mehh, too many players are trying to convince me to go fire.. Posted Image

I know how you feel, but feeling that I have the rotation down really well for frost and rank regularly now (sometimes quite high), and the fire mage 4 ilvl below me in guild blew me out of the water in his logs (I just transferred), I feel pretty much obligated to give up frost. I have noticed it just isn't scaling as well as I had hoped, and it has been a while since I have played arcane and fire.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thanks for all the help guys. fire seemed to run excellent in a raid environment the other night. now all I need to do is practice my ignite building further to become optimal. cheers guys!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hey

it's me again

i've got big trouble

i've changed spec into fire

now i have - http://eu.battle.net/wow/ru/character/%D0%B3%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%B4%D1%83%D0%BD%D0%BD%D0%B8/%D0%91%D0%BB%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BD/advanced

but!!!

dps decreased in times! i dunno why

i realy dun understand

http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/rt-sj130d4l684nzs13/

i see myself in 50+-% of fire mage dash and it depressed me

help plz

what's wrong?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll try to dive into the log tomorrow if I get time (sorry real life is very busy right now) but for now i'll post a link to Vykina's Fire mage opener. It's a good breakdown of how to open plus how to use the Heating up Trick. Maybe it will help some.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i have not very best english language skills (especially listening is not my strongest side), that's why i don't understand key point of vykina's heating up using

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, I've tried to analyze the WoL... But it's in Russian, so I gave up. The link you gave for armory is broken, in fact I found your character after a bit of search.

I don't really have anything to compare to your logs, yet because I just myself started playing fire on Sunday and only have logs for Dark Animus and bosses after that. I will get back to this topic after our Wednesday's raid that time I should be able to compare my logs to yours. :)

But, to be frank. I don't think that your crit rating is high enough yet, for the damage that you are expecting. Mine as well is pretty low... I've been collecting gear for frost spec, and I have also no item with base crit on it, so it sucks.. :D

Could you describe your opener and how you line up Combustion with Alter Time and your trinket procs and other CDs?

What is your basic rotation when you have cooldown on Combustion?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Burnt
      Hey guys,

      I'd appreciate if you could have a look at my trinket sims. I'm a little bit confused about the results, so maybe you could tell me if it seems correct?

      For BoS people say strength > all, but SC reccommends me 2 non strength trinkets. 
      For ST it's Faulty Countermeasure (900) and Unstable Arcanocrystal (865).
      For MT Horn of Valor (865) and Unstable Arcanocrystal (865).

      None of them has strength, could that really be the right choice for BoS?
      I also have Convergence of Fates (875), which is not reccommended as top choice, but i know Simcraft undervalues it a little bit - at least that's what i've heard.

      I run mostly M+ and only 1 day per week Nighthold, so my thoughts were to use the following combinations:
      For M+ Arcanocrystal (865) / Countermeasure (900) with tyrannical affix and Arcanocrystal (865) / Horn (865) for other trash affixes.
      For raiding i thought Countermeasure (900) / CoF (875) would be best, because CoF should be more valuable in longer fights.

      What do you think?

      Character: 
      http://eu.battle.net/wow/de/character/tirion/Mìho/simple

      Sim singletarget:
      http://xsooom.com/wow/trinkets170215_1t.html

      Sim 3 targets:
      http://xsooom.com/wow/trinkets170215_3t.html

      (Results are in german... but i hope most of the trinket names are still understandable. Currently equipped is FC/IA.)

      Thanks in advance!
    • By Ulathar
      Hey folks,
      I play frost since TBC and since i got my hands on my 3rd legendary and 2 part t19 bonus i struggle with my current build. Maybe you can enlight me :). Here we go:
      I am at an avg gs of 888 with the following stats (unbuffed):
      30% crit
      20% haste
      31% mastery
      3% versatility
      I have the Bracers, cape and belt legendarys at my proposal, currently running with bracers + belt.
      I used to play the "normal" OBRA Build (Icy talons, Frozen Pulse, Runic Attenuation and Glacial Advance)  and did quite well. Since i got my 2 part t19 bonus i am somewhat ressource overcapped and/or GCD limited. Thats why i started tinkering around with my talents.
      Currently i play around with:
      Murderous Efficiency
      Gathering Storm
      Freezing Fog

      Instead of the "normal" OBRA build. I am still not sure if this build yields better dps or not for me. Depending on proc luck i am still overcapped with ressources some times as well as ressource starved at other times cuz of the missing Runic Attenuation talent.
       
      What do you guys think? I tried the BoS build as well but i absolutely HATE its "playstyle". can't get used to that 2 min cooldown. Most of the time I use it in a raid i get some nasty debuff and have to run -> dropping BoS xD. In mythic+ i don't like it as well because it falls off after one pack and takes 2-3 packs until its ready again...
       
      And the last question:
      would you prefere a 880 Chest + 880 trinket (that egg thing with the poor haste proc) over Nightbane Chest at 875 alongside with the eye of command at 860?
    • By Tutsumi
      Okay, so for my gear I  (and my raid leaders) really think I should be doing more damage on fights.  I'm mainly specced for single fights, and I tend not to switch over - but even on single target fights it seems too low.  I've tried to match up my procs for best timing and also using them whenever they're off cool down - including my Troll racial.
      Here's my Warcraft Logs - https://www.warcraftlogs.com/rankings/character/19432781/latest
      My armory - http://us.battle.net/wow/en/character/stormreaver/Tutsumi/advanced
    • By Rinayu
      Hi!
      I'm reviewing some of my logs from previous raids, and am wondering how you guys rate the importance of Gathering Storm, and whether you actively try to only have 3 runes regenerating or if you let Gathering Storm just take a back seat and don't focus on it.
      From some research I found that it does have a massive effect on the dps, when successfully extending your Gathering Storm from 10 stacks to a re-cast which refreshes the duration with 10 stacks it can have a huge impact as shown in the below log. (Check Buff Uptimes)
      https://www.warcraftlogs.com/reports/GdFYfB6hxgzRncKr#fight=18

      Please let me know if you've done any personal research and any insight. :)
    • By Orpheus1772
      Hey everyone,
      Im interested in the general achievable uptime of BoS, since I neither have the legendary belt, nor the T19 P4 boni, I can only make it to ~55 seconds with Hungering Rune Weapon + Horn, and I feel like Im doing something wrong here, because the second Breath wont have those 2 runeweapon charges and I can only get it to ~20-25 sec, while the third one goes to ~40 sec again.
      I have a better chest (Kara chest)+trinket and shoulder, but the 20% increased proc chance for howling blast sounds to good to pass up, but at the same time Im making the mistake of trying to not waste HB procs, which results in RP loss overall.
      Whats the uptime for those who have the belt, ring and t19 4p bonus?
       
      normal 3 3 2 3 2 3 2 build
      doing fine with the normal obliterate build, but got tired of it and wanted to try breath.
      http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/norgannon/Ôrpheus/simple