L0rinda

Design Team Comment on Health of Hearthstone and Yogg

7 posts in this topic

pOSom9b.jpg

IGN have conducted a very interesting interview with Designers Mike Donais and Dean Ayala regarding the health of Hearthstone at the moment.

The article covers a lot of the questions that have been raised by the community recently. Donais admits there is more Shaman on ladder than he would like right now, but seems comfortable waiting to see if it dies down when players stop experimenting with new builds (Presumably with regards to Spirit Claws). He talks a bit about Priest, and the implication is that Priest will probably be helped in the next set.

He also comments on Yogg-Saron, Hope's End, saying "Yogg-Saron is definitely on our radar." This is probably no real cause for excitement just yet, but it's good to see that they are taking a look. The whole article, in fact, is a reminder of how much the design team are constantly monitoring all kinds of statistics. It is also good that they are aware of which current decks that require high skill caps, as many players believe that Hearthstone needs high skill cap decks to be credible as an esport.

Blizzard LogoIksar  (Dean Ayala)

Yeah, like the Raging Worgen Warrior, Anyfin Paladin, Miracle Rogue, Freeze Mage is still being played, and this Malygos Druid, and all of those decks are very very complex, and all have some amount of success on ladder right now. 

The second half of the article talks in-depth about the how the changes to the Arena were made. As always, it is fascinating to read how the design team reaches their decisions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How much would it impact the usefulness of Yogg if it only played your class' spells? I imagine he'd become even better for some classes, even worse for others?

Maybe even restrict the maximum number of spells he can cast?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Blainie said:

How much would it impact the usefulness of Yogg if it only played your class' spells? I imagine he'd become even better for some classes, even worse for others?

Maybe even restrict the maximum number of spells he can cast?

I'd like to see him only cast spells up to the amount of mana cast on spells during the game so far. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A question I would like to ask Hearthstone Research&Development team would probably be "do you put "fun" in "fundamental" (excuse this horrible pun)"

How much do they value a factor of fun? How do they even measure this if they do, and are we put to mercy of their judgment on the subject? 

Is "not fun", "frustrating to play as\against" a relevant argument in some decisions? Because oh boy, they'd definetly showed us they hate fun when Miracle and Patron were nerfed, Kappa.

Perhaps I'm just a fun hater and I'm definetly not a qualified game designer, but when I'm thinking about some things that can be in the game but they aren't : mechanics, interactions, whole dimensions and axises (axi?) of gameplay, maybe it's all left behind because "it ain't fun", and if it so, I'd like to know about it. And the other option is "R&D is stupid" which sucks. 

My opinion is that "fun" should be a secondary factor if you try to brand a game as competitive, even as an E-Sports discipline.

 


Regarding the actual interview, I didn't like the Priest part and their "trick" explaination. Personally I don't feel like weird stuff is a part of Priest's identity from the original game, i mean, guys have a healing spell called "Heal". And "Great Heal" which heals more. And "Flash Heal" that heals fast. And then there are spells like "Power Word : Shield" or ":Pain" or ":Death", guess what they do, too.

If you position a class like that, like a "trick class", there is no way it's going to work out any way, because when it doesn't, it sucks, and when it does, you nerf it, or it happens like once in a lifetime and it still sucks. Priest should have more basic feel, down-to-earth design, with actual creatures, killing spells and card draws, because that's what Hearthstone at its Heart is all about, and as I explained, Priest is a pretty "basic" class for what it's worth. Well, it used to be.

Just look at the other "Trick Class", Rogue. They are actually viable, because their tricks are "normal" - as much as "normal" can a turn 3 10\10 Van Cleef be, he is still just a big dumb beater, and so on.

Dragon Priest was a good shot. Even a LoE Control Priest felt like a normal deck. If they stop messing around and put on their thinking caps, we can have a game with 9 classes but without the 9th class. And that would be great.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, L0rinda said:

I'd like to see him only cast spells up to the amount of mana cast on spells during the game so far. 

This was more along the lines of what I meant. Something that stops those super cheap druid spells turning into something worth 15-20 times the mana.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Aleco

      Aleco walks through a series of simple early-game decisions while playing an Unstable Evolution deck.
      "Simple early game decisions" and "multi-turn decisions" are the two most common requests I've been receiving since the start of this series, so I decided to do an episode that tackles both! In today's episode I navigate a series of relatively simple early-game decisions against an aggressive Hunter start with my Unstable Evolution Shaman deck.
      If you have any requests for future episodes of "What's the Move?", please feel free to reach out to me here on Icy Veins or via Twitter @Aleco_P. I prefer to always fulfill requests for new episodes if possible, and always love hearing feedback from the community which can help me improve on this series in the future. Don't be shy!
      If you're looking for the guide I referenced in this video, please follow this link to "Legend in the Making: Part 2". 
    • By Zadina

      This promotion runs for the next month.
      The latest Twitch Prime promotion for Hearthstone is now active. Sign up for Twitch Prime until February 10 and you will receive two free Kobolds & Catacombs card packs.
      Blizzard Entertainment
      We’re digging the latest reward for Twitch Prime members: two Kobolds and Catacombs card packs!

      January 10 through February 10, unearth the value for yourself by signing up for Twitch Prime. You’ll get all the benefits that come with Prime, including special Prime Loot for other Blizzard games!
      It’s easy to become a Twitch Prime member—just link your Amazon Prime account to your Twitch account to start earning rewards. Not an Amazon Prime member? Sign up for a free trial today!
      *Offer valid only in regions where Twitch Prime is available. Must own Hearthstone to redeem. Each Blizzard account may only redeem one code per promotional item. (source)
      Ever since its introduction, Twitch Prime has offered free stuff on Hearthstone every 2 to 3 months. It also has rewards in other games from Blizzard and other companies, so you should read up on it! It might be a worthwhile investment for people who enjoy multiple games.
    • By Aleco

      Choose your champion for the upcoming Hearthstone World Championships to win free K&C packs!
      The biggest Hearthstone tournament of the year, the Hearthstone World Championship, is just around the corner! To help build up excitement for the tournament, players may now select a champion from among the 16 world championship competitors. Each round your champion advances in the tournament will reward you with more Kobolds & Catacombs packs. You can win up to 6 packs of K&C for selecting the winner of the tournament, so choose wisely! Once you've locked in your choice it can not be changed.
      Anyone with a Battle.net account can select a champion for free until midnight on January 17th (Pacific Standard Time), and there's no downside to selecting the wrong champion. All you need to do is follow this link and select one of the 16 competitors. Personally, I'm sticking with Purple because he won me 3 packs at the Summer Championship and appears to be the favorite to win his group. Kolento and Surrender are two of the favorites to win the tournament, which would make them safe bets to win you some packs as well.
    • By Zadina

      After a couple of repeats, this is 2018's first new Tavern Brawl.
      This is a constructed Brawl, with the novelty that you can build a deck of any size. The rest of the cards will be Shadow Reflections, which is normally generated by the passive Hero Power of the Rogue Death Knight Valeera the Hollow. It should be noted that when you play second, you don't get the coin; you draw an extra card instead.
      Obviously, you don't want to make a deck of 30 cards, since you will have no Shadow Reflections (although people have had success even like this). However, you also don't want to make a deck of only 1-3 cards, given that the Reflections take actual spots in the deck and it will be hard drawing the cards you picked.
      By doing a quick research, it seems that Aggro Paladin and Aggro Druid are good picks. As is usually the case when some good decks surface, their counters are also created: in this case, it's Mage with Ice Lance and Combo Priest. Moreover, Quest Rogue has managed to make a surprise re-appearance from the dead in this Brawl. Lastly, a hilarious deck is the Hunter one with Mechwarper and Metaltooth Leaper.
      Good luck!