Stan

Ben Brode AMA Summary: July 14

12 posts in this topic

V7L9skG.jpg

Hearthstone Game Director Ben Brode did an AMA on reddit yesterday and here's a summary with the most interesting highlihts.

  • Blizzard didn't want to reveal 1 card a day for the new expansion, because the feedback they were getting was that hype was slowing down as they got closer to the expansion. Cards will be revealed on July 24.
  • They would like to make Handlock a thing again, but Brode's worried with their ability to make Handlock insane in Standard going forward, with new cards, without pushing it into insanity in Wild. It can be done in Wild by moving cards that are buffing it, or by making entirely new cards in Standard that are good in both formats. 
  • When asked about free cards on a weekly rotation, Brode said they wouldn't be doing it due to its complexity, but the team is exploring other options with similar, less complex goals.
  • The team internally experiments with various formats to keep the game fresh e.g. by changing the ladder format for the last month of a set.
  • Each class will have a hero card and a legendary minion in Knights of the Frozen Throne expansion.
  • New ladder experience is in the works with the goals to reduce the monthly grind for top-level players, increase progression for bottom 25% of player, better match-making and improve new player ranked experience.
  • Hearthstone won't be coming to consoles anytime soon.
  • Ice Block is a card that matches their red flags for cards that shouldn't be in Standard forever.
  • They will continue to add more features to the collection manager.
  • The team will make a new Druid and Warlock hero. Regarding Tyrande, the goal was to find alternative ways for regions that were not eligible for the offer to get access to Tyrande and they've been working with their regional offices to make it happen.
  • More minion-placement cards will be added to the game.
  • Blizzard's working on a way to provide more stats to players, but Brode doesn't like "profile" pages.
  • The main goals with the upcoming ladder rework are
    • Reduce grind for top-level players
    • Increase progression for players stuck at rank 20-ish
    • Get better matchmaking for bottom 25% players
    • Make experience better for new players
  • The biggest challenging is making those things better without losing what they like about the current system.
  • Specating mode is definitely a place with a lot of room for improvement.
  • New opportunities are on the horizon to earn packs of the new set through upcoming events and single-player missions that will be free with the new set.
  • They're going to bring back Wild cards for sale, which should make Wild more accessible.
  • No plans to add another class, they have plans for more unique things for Warlocks and a 10th class wouldn't be helpful. The time should be spent to make the core classes more fun.
  • Adding the Hall of Fame in Un'Goro and hitting those 6 cards allowed them to see the "freshest" meta yet. 
  • Changes to arena rewards are coming. Details TBA.
  • Hero cards are a new thing that replaces your hero, not transforms them.

(Source)

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Stan said:

Ice Block is a card that matches their red flags for cards that shouldn't be in Standard forever.

Good news indeed. :D

5 hours ago, Stan said:

The team will make a new Druid and Warlock hero

It's about damn time. :D

5 hours ago, Stan said:

They would like to make Handlock a thing again

Yay! :D

5 hours ago, Stan said:

More minion-placement cards will be added to the game.

More yay! :D

5 hours ago, Stan said:

The main goals with the upcoming ladder rework are

  • Reduce grind for top-level players
  • Increase progression for players stuck at rank 20-ish
  • Get better matchmaking for bottom 25% players
  • Make experience better for new players

Good news but I do fear that they might muck it up. I am going to be optimistic on this one. 

5 hours ago, Stan said:

No plans to add another class, they have plans for more unique things for Warlocks

I'm happy about this as Warlock is one of my favorite classes but I am sad that we won't be getting a DK class. Good news for your wallet @positiv2 ;)

4 hours ago, Dustintime said:

Ben Brode has an odd resemblance to that actor fellow.

Seth Rogan? 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, KingMe said:

[Re Ice Block's potential removal from Standard] Good news indeed. :D 

As someone who likes to play Quest Mage a lot (Giants version, not endless Fireball), I disagree. Without Ice block, I don't see how the Mage quest can possibly work, because its tough enough as it is now. Not unless some new card is added.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, h3llbee said:

As someone who likes to play Quest Mage a lot (Giants version, not endless Fireball), I disagree. Without Ice block, I don't see how the Mage quest can possibly work, because its tough enough as it is now. Not unless some new card is added.

I agree. I don't see Quest Mage working without it but at the same time I would like to see mage work period without the need for Ice Block

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Love Blizzard trying to make Handlock a thing again, but honestly most of the best decks gameplay wise and most balanced decks have been discovered by community, not handed on a plate by Blizzard. The decks Blizzard want to push to viability end up being decks like Taunt warrior and Secret Paladin, decks that are both uninteractive and very often pretty autopilot as well. The argument of "not making it insane in wild" is completely just a bad excuse, as with that logic N'Zoth for example would never have been printed ever. Keeping wild balanced is while still trying to make standard meta less stale is borderline impossible, and I would like Blizzard just to give up on trying to pay attention to wild balance, as it griefs the development of standard too much.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, BrightwingMain said:

Love Blizzard trying to make Handlock a thing again, but honestly most of the best decks gameplay wise and most balanced decks have been discovered by community, not handed on a plate by Blizzard. The decks Blizzard want to push to viability end up being decks like Taunt warrior and Secret Paladin, decks that are both uninteractive and very often pretty autopilot as well. The argument of "not making it insane in wild" is completely just a bad excuse, as with that logic N'Zoth for example would never have been printed ever. Keeping wild balanced is while still trying to make standard meta less stale is borderline impossible, and I would like Blizzard just to give up on trying to pay attention to wild balance, as it griefs the development of standard too much.

Most of the decks that ended up being tier 1 were obviously "intentional" - Patron Warrior, Secret Paladin, C'thun decks, Quest decks, OTK Murloc pally, so on. Anyway, it's hard to tell whether a deck was "handed on a plate by Blizzard", as the only decks they provide are deck recipes, and giving one deck for each class is often not enough to showcase all ideas they had.

I agree with you on the wild excuse. Currently, the (arguably) strongest deck in wild is Pirate Warrior, which is a standard deck with only 1 wild card in it - Ship's Cannon. It's obvious that even though blizzard said Wild allows them to print low-power cards so that it doesn't spiral out of control, they are so far unsuccessful.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, positiv2 said:

Currently, the (arguably) strongest deck in wild is Pirate Warrior, which is a standard deck with only 1 wild card in it - Ship's Cannon. It's obvious that even though blizzard said Wild allows them to print low-power cards so that it doesn't spiral out of control, they are so far unsuccessful.

Not convinced it's the best wild deck, just the best easy-to-play wild deck. But anyway, it also runs Sir Finley, and often a Death's Bite or two. And Ship's Cannon is a pretty big boost to the power of the deck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dislike Ice Block because unlike all other secrets there are no ways to play around it. You need to deliver a lethal damage to win so there are no way to not proc the secret.  

I wouldn't mind it as much if we had enough cards like Curse of Rafaam to play around the effect.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Strongpoint said:

I dislike Ice Block because unlike all other secrets there are no ways to play around it. You need to deliver a lethal damage to win so there are no way to not proc the secret.  

I wouldn't mind it as much if we had enough cards like Curse of Rafaam to play around the effect.

 

You can absolutely play around it if you add a situational card like Eater of Secrets to your deck, The meta is so full of secrets right now that you can really get a lot of play out of that card. There are few things more enjoyable then dropping that card to remove an Ice Block and pushing through lethal damage.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 hours ago, Bozonik said:

Not convinced it's the best wild deck, just the best easy-to-play wild deck. But anyway, it also runs Sir Finley, and often a Death's Bite or two. And Ship's Cannon is a pretty big boost to the power of the deck.

#1 on tempostorm's meta snapshot, #4 on vicious syndicate's report, and #1 on hsreplay.

Not all variations run these cards. Some omit them, yet they remain powerful. You will also see a lot of standard decks on wild ladder, often past rank 5.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 17/07/2017 at 11:18 PM, positiv2 said:

#1 on tempostorm's meta snapshot, #4 on vicious syndicate's report, and #1 on hsreplay.

Not all variations run these cards. Some omit them, yet they remain powerful. You will also see a lot of standard decks on wild ladder, often past rank 5.

Yeah, I played wild last season, plenty of standard decks out there. But the standard of play is much weaker too, pushing to Legend was way easier than in Standard, and that's without any prior knowledge of the wild meta too.

Meta snapshots are interesting, but easy-to-play decks get overrated compared to decks that are hard to play well but are stronger with optimal play. Playing out patches on turn 1 in pirate warrior is almost always a horrible play, which I saw a surprising amount in wild, but it'll cost less wins than mulliganing badly in control Shaman, etc. And meta snapshots include all the bad plays, so an optimal-play meta snapshot would look very different imo, were such a thing possible.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Zadina

      The two Hearthstone developers talked to IGN about the design process behind some of the most impactful cards from Kobolds & Catacombs.
      First of all, Peter Whalen and Mike Donais confirmed that there will be an update on February, a month after the World Championship. This patch will contain new events and possibly balance changes. They will take a look at the meta as it's been and as it is in the World Championship and they will decide accordingly.
      Moving on, they talked about some of the classes and how K&C cards have affected them. Starting with Warlock, Cubelock was a deck that was tested internally and it was an archetype the team was "certainly concerned about and [they] played a bunch of games with it". Carnivorous Cube was also tested internally in Recruit Hunter and in Quest Druid. As far as Possessed Lackey is concerned, there was a second version of it that read "Battlecry: If you control a Demon, Recruit a Demon", while Dark Pact was 0 mana at some point. Lastly, Rin, the First Disciple's seals used to have different effects and Azari, the Devourer was a 15/15 untargetable minion.
      The two devs talked next about the other dominating class of the current meta: Priest. Mike Donais pointed out that Highlander Priest was already doing well, so it was only given one new card: Psychic Scream. On the other hand. Big Priest has a pretty medium win rate, even though it can feel frustrating to play against. It's also a deck that will lose several cards in the upcoming rotation. At this point, the devs repeated that they are looking forward to develop and see in action new playstyles in the post-Barnes era. Finally, during the design process Twilight's Call could summon any minion, not just Deathrattles, but this was deemed too powerful.
      The next class to be discussed was Rogue. The team is happy with how balanced the Kingsbane Rogue deck turned out to be. Some internal iterations of the Rogue legendary weapon were dual-wielded daggers or a weapon that had the Battlecry: Discover a card, everything you draw is a copy of that. Mike also talked about Valeera the Hollow: he expected her to be more powerful than she already is, but maybe players will find a way to use her more in the future.
      There were a few words about Hearthstone's currently weakest class: Shaman. The devs think that the Shaman Spellstone is a powerful "sleeper" card, although maybe there's presently not a proper deck for it. They were also slightly worried about Unstable Evolution. Another "sleeper" card for them is Warrior's Drywhisker Armorer.
      An important point is that when asked about Corridor Creeper, Peter said that it's "one of the cards that raised a red flag". Lastly, they talked about King Togwaggle and the numerous iterations he had - all around swapping decks with your opponent. The penalty on the spell card isn't high enough on purpose, because they didn't want Togwaggle to be a super competitive card.
      I've tried to summarise the most important points, but you should definitely check out the entire interview on IGN. There's much more detail behind the design process of Kobolds & Catacombs, while there is also temp artwortk of cards as well as two cards that never made it into the game!
    • By Aleco

      Players can earn up to three free packs for logging in to Hearthstone during the Hearthstone World Championships.
      The folks over at Hearthpwn.com have learned from data mining of patch 10.0 that the Hearthstone World Championships will offer players three free packs as daily login rewards. The first day of the championships will give players a Journey to Un'Goro pack, the second day a Knights of the Frozen Throne pack, and the third a Kobolds & Catacombs pack. The Hearthstone home screen will also change to sparkling white theme honor the World Championships.

      Along with this week's awesome Tavern Brawl featuring World Championship winning decks, this marks the first time that Blizzard has brought Hearthstone eSports all the way to the Hearthstone client. Given the recent start of the Overwatch League and the choose your champion feature for the World Championships, it seems that Blizzard is supporting competitive gaming now more than ever.
    • By Zadina

      This week's Brawl honours the 3 previous Hearthstone World Champions!
      The 2018 World Championship is about to begin and Team 5 is celebrating by giving us a very special Tavern Brawl. In this Brawl, you get to play with decks that the previous world champions from 2014, 2015 and 2016 used on their way to the top. Your player name will even change to the respective Champion: Firebat, Ostkaka or Pavel!
      Here are the deck archetypes you can get:
      Firebat's Undertaker Hunter Firebat's Ramp Druid Firebat's Miracle Rogue Firebat's Zoolock Ostkaka's Patron Warrior Ostkaka's Oil Rogue Ostkaka's Freeze Mage Pavel's Tempo Mage Pavel's Malygos Miracle Rogue Pavel's Midrange Shaman Pavel's C'Thun Warrior Pavel's Malygos OTK Druid You might think: "why would I want to play a deck from 2014 with cards that have been nerfed"? Well, all cards are on their pre-nerfed versions, therefore they are basically in the same state as when originally used by each World Champion. So, say hello to pre-nerf Undertaker, Leper Gnome, Hex and many others.
      Amnesiac can never catch a break.
      A slight inconsistency is that cards that generate other cards or tokens, like Piloted Shredder or Babbling Book, can generate cards/tokens from later expansions. For example, my opponent's dead Shredder created Friendly Bartender, a card that neither Champion had encountered at their time.
      Enjoy the Brawl and tune in to the World Championship this weekend!
    • By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our HCT World Championships coverage.
    • By Aleco

      Aleco walks through a series of simple early-game decisions while playing an Unstable Evolution deck.
      "Simple early game decisions" and "multi-turn decisions" are the two most common requests I've been receiving since the start of this series, so I decided to do an episode that tackles both! In today's episode I navigate a series of relatively simple early-game decisions against an aggressive Hunter start with my Unstable Evolution Shaman deck.
      If you have any requests for future episodes of "What's the Move?", please feel free to reach out to me here on Icy Veins or via Twitter @Aleco_P. I prefer to always fulfill requests for new episodes if possible, and always love hearing feedback from the community which can help me improve on this series in the future. Don't be shy!
      If you're looking for the guide I referenced in this video, please follow this link to "Legend in the Making: Part 2".