Aleco

Elven Minstrel Reveal: Kobolds & Catacombs

Sign in to follow this  

8 posts in this topic

34410-sonya-shadowdancer-reveal-kobolds-

Elven Minstrel is on my shortlist for "most powerful card in the set". And we're not even done with spoilers!

Upon reading this new Rogue card for the first time I was in disbelief. I said "Is this a real card?!" out loud to myself, and even went to multiple sources to confirm that what I saw was actually the card revealed today by Nalguidan and wasn't some kind of misprint.

It's really that good. Don't believe me? Have a look for yourself:

elvenminstril.png

 

Draw two minions from your deck... For 4 mana... And a 3/2?!

What else needs to be said? It feels to me like Rogue just got a 4 mana version of Ultimate Infestation. I'm calling it now, people will be making reddit posts about Elven Minstrel just like this one before too long. Between this card and Sonya Shadowdancer, Rogue looks like its going to be a force to be reckoned with in K&C.

Do you think Rogue will be the top class in K&C? Let us know what you think in the comment section, and be sure to check out our Kobolds and Catacombs hub for more information on the upcoming set.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Think this is "good" but not as OP as the op said.   It's not really a 4 mana card, unless you have a backstab or coin handy which will be rare.    What'll probably happen is it averages out as a 5-6 cost 3/2, draw two random minions.    Which again is "good" but not broken, it comes fairly late and rogue doesn't exactly play the find a win-condition creature game, rogue (at least right now) is winning with Prince and a load of pirates/jade.   

To bring it further into perspective, if you're on turn 3 and have a coin as a rogue, would you rather play this and get 2 creatures in hand, or play a 2/3 Jade Spirit and get another creature in play that also upgrades your Jade growth count?    I would also argue that Xaril provides similar value, and is also "good" but not "broken".

 

Edited by Migol
comparison

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's some serious value. Arcane intellect + 1 mana 3/2 body sounds pretty insane. 

To be fair you could say that it will cost about 5 mana to get the effect, because combo, but still, strong card.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree. A strong card but not too strong imo. When you play it, it's a bad stats minion for it's cost and you lose tempo (ofc you will compensate that in the next turn). And I'm sure everyone is already seeing that thing shadow stepped :D 

Edited by Caldyrvan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This card is going to be bonkers strong in miracle rogue.  Thinning minions out of your deck makes your miracle turn much stronger.  Also, not drawing auctioneer is one of the most soul crushing feelings ever.  Also a problem miracle rogues tend to have is not drawing minions, since the deck is realatively light on them, and situations where you have 5 cards in your and with a total combine Mana cost of 3 or so is also common, so being able to fish for minions when you want then is very appealing. On a side note, since miracle does run so much draw it might only be a 1 of in it but that doesn't really make it any less stupid strong in the archtype.   As for tempo rogue, maybe this will see play, a 4 drop that gets traded up by 2 drops can be bad.  The effect is still probably strong enough that it will be included though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's not even comparable to UI, it doesn't heal nor do damage, the minion is a 2 mana value and even need combo to be of use and is just 2 cards not the whole deck like UI.

That said is an acceptable card can be played and has synergy with the new rogue cards.

Btw a druid is very likely to play UI in the turn you play this and he will show you what broken is... considering they still play UI at 5th turn since the nerf weren't enough to bring druid between common mortals

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Migol said:

   It's not really a 4 mana card, unless you have a backstab or coin handy which will be rare. 

Or Preparation or Shadowstep, which are both cards that are used extremely often. It also synergises extremely well with cards like Sonya Shadowdancer and Shadowcaster, for when you indeed want to combo it for even more card draw.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Yridaa said:
Quote

Or Preparation or Shadowstep, which are both cards that are used extremely often. It also synergises extremely well with cards like Sonya Shadowdancer and Shadowcaster, for when you indeed want to combo it for even more card draw.  

Yes to preparation (though a waste if you have no spell to use), but using shadowstep as the first spell in a turn is extremely rare.    The point is the cost entails more than 4 mana, at best it's "4 mana and a usable 0 cast card, otherwise 5 or more mana".      Again, it's a good card, but I'd value it at the same place as Xaril, which provides very similar value.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Aleco
      A new Hearthside Chat video gave us a sneak peek of Puzzle Labs in action.
       
      Today's Hearthside Chat shed some light on Puzzle Labs, the new single player content for The Boomsday Project releasing on August 21st. We already knew that Lethal, Mirror, Board Clear, and Survival were going to be the 4 puzzle types, but developers Giovanni Scarpati and Max Ma helped reveal the Puzzle Lab menus and UI, as well as some of the backstory on how Puzlle Labs came to be. Watch the video below to get a sneak peek of Puzzle Labs in action:
       
       
    • By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our Control Warrior Guide.
    • By Stan
      After 9 years, Production Director Yong Woo left Blizzard entertainment to join Ben Brode's new game company called Second Dinner.
      Production Director Yong Woo joined Brode's indie company according to his latest tweet.
      Placeholder for tweet 1029786314365796352 There's also a video of Brode welcoming both on board. According to Hearthpwn, there are now 5 ex-Hearthstone developers working at Second Dinner.
      (Source)
    • By positiv2
      This thread is for comments about our Spell Damage Mage deck.
    • By Zadina
      The latest Hearthstone community contribution allows you to train the skills needed to master Combo Priest: quick thinking, fast mouse movements, strategic decisions and on-the-spot calculations. What's more to ask?!
      Combo or OTK or APM Priest is a reiteration of Combo and Vivid Nightmare Priest that was born with The Boomsday Project thanks to two cards: Topsy Turvy and Test Subject. Dog is credited as the creator and true master of the deck:
      Many have subsequently tried and failed to pilot the deck, which can require almost 100 moves during the 75 seconds of a single turn. Pro players like Trump and Thijs have hilariously failed, while others like Disguised Toast and Kolento kept trying until they got the hang of it.
      Right now, you might be dreading that you don't have the IQ to play this deck. Fear no more: everything can be practiced and Patashu has made the tool for it! Combo Priest Simulator allows you to practice the OTK combo on your browser, while also timing you. You can change the parameters of the starting gamestate, too.
      In all seriousness, the deck's winrate is below average and it's honestly too much trouble for too little gain. Then again, slamming your opponent's face for 100+ damage is quite satisfactory. It would be awesome if someone was brave enough to bring this deck at a tournament: it would be the casters' nightmare!
      Apart from Combo Priest Simulator, we have a guide for Topsy Turvy OTK Priest here on Icy Veins; the guide breaks down the necessary steps of the combo in a useful priority list. Alternatively, you can listen to Aleco trying to explain how the deck works to Patrick (and actually succeeding) in the latest Icy Veins Podcast!