Jump to content
FORUMS
Sign in to follow this  
Zadina

Iksar on Basic and Classic Sets

Recommended Posts

41407-iksar-on-odd-paladin-druid-baku-mo

Dean "Iksar" Ayala was active on Reddit yesterday commenting on the purpose and the design philosophy behind the Basic and Classic sets as well as the reasoning behind nerfs on cards from these sets.

The Lead Balance Designer explained that the Basic and Classic sets' purpose is to introduce players to the game's mechanics and the fantasies behind each class. Since these sets are always around, powerful cards in them can be frustrating and cause negativity. For example, Wild Growth and Nourish were under the scope for a nerf for a long time. That doesn't mean all Basic and Classic cards have to be weak; some of them, like Fireball, Al'Akir the Windlord, Frothing Berserker and Tirion Fordring, are powerful, they show off class fantasy well enough and are safe from any changes (for now!).

Card nerfs aren't meant to just solve short-term problems. For example, the Fiery War Axe nerf made it possible for other Warrior weapons to see play. It's true that nerfing cards from the Classic and Basic cards makes players feel obligated to invest their gold or real money on newly released sets. The team has tried to offset this with more seasonal events, as well as the reworked new player experience, which all give packs to players.

Blizzard LogoIksarHS

Ideally the basic and classic set show off the kinds of mechanics each class is about without having too many cards that show up in all possible class archetypes. Basic is important to us because it serves as a set of cards players can use to learn about the game before they choose whether or not to make an investment of their time or money. Classic is important to us because it serves as the secondary jump-off point where you learn the baseline for what each of the individual classes is about along with some of our core mechanics like Battlecry or Deathrattle. From a gameplay perspective, having these sets around forever usually only leads to negativity when the cards are so powerful they show up in every deck in every expansion, making the strategies players use feel more stale than they would otherwise. We've been trying to change some of these power outliers over time, but only when making that change might also be positive for the live game environment. Wild Growth and Nourish were good examples of cards we had thought about changing for some time, so when we arrived in a meta where Druid had been very powerful and popular for a long time, it felt like a good time for those changes. We'd like to continue making these types of changes, as we believe the game will be in a better position to meet the player expectation that the game is new and fresh from expansion to expansion.

We nerf basic/classic cards that are too powerful instead of rotating them when they hit on class fantasy but at too high of a power level. Ramping mana is a strong identifier for what Druid should be about, so it made more sense to us to have some of the simplest forms of mana ramp exist in the base set to teach players what Druids can be about. It also makes more sense to have those cards be medium power level because if we identify mana ramp as an identity for Druids, it would be nice to be able to make some mana ramp cards from time to time without having to create cards even more powerful than two of the (arguably) most powerful cards in the game. Of course, this doesn't mean all basic and classic cards have to be weak. Generally the cards we target for change are ones that exist in every archetype. Cards like Al'Akir, Frothing, Fireball, or Tirion are probably safe. They are powerful and do an awesome job at selling the class fantasy for the class they represent. They also have some weaknesses and you can imagine an archetype within their class that might not play them. This is a pretty good place to be in. (source)


I probably should have included this in the first post. It's true that reducing the amount of auto-include cards in the base set makes cards from expansions more important if the goal is to be able to create every powerful deck. This is something that's more healthy to solve with things like gold injection events like fire festival, increasing the gold on the average quest, or having a new player experience that awards 20+ packs. We keep a close eye on the the kind of investment it takes (time or currency) to obtain a deck archetype that is fun and powerful. The end goal is to make that a painless experience and there is more than one way to go about that. Having a wide variety of forever cards that are so high power level they are included in most decks is one way to go about it, I just don't think it's the right one.  (source)


The main point I think is important to get across here is that we don't ever change basic and classic cards just to solve short-term problems. Warrior was fairly powerful at the time we changed FWA which I think makes the change more palatable. If we truly thought that Warrior was better served in the long-term by have FWA as a (2) mana card, then we certainly would have tried to change expansion level cards rather than something in the classic set. Cards like Sul'thraze, Supercollider, Woodcutter's Axe, and Bloodrazer have all had a little more room to breathe and make Warrior feel different expansion to expansion as a result of the FWA change, which was part of the goal. (source)

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our Jambre's Rank 4 Legend Highlander Galakrond Rogue Deck.
    • By Damien
      This thread is for comments about our PapaJason's Top 50 Legend Reno Mage Deck.
    • By Stan
      Update 17.0 came with a few bugs that need fixing, so Blizzard outlined a hotfix schedule for the next two weeks.
      Blizzard (Source)
      We are currently in the process of putting out a few hotfixes for issues introduced after the 17.0 update. Please note that these fixes take place on the server side, so you should not need to download anything if you’ve updated to 17.0.
      We’ve identified and fixed an issue that could cause the game to fail to offer some eligible players the Returning Player Experience. Affected players should now receive the appropriate quest line when logging into Hearthstone. Whizbang the Wonderful will no longer offer decks with cards that have moved to the Hall of Fame. Kingsbane will now correctly be destroyed and shuffled into your deck when it reaches 0 durability. Living Roots, when disenchanted, now properly gives the amount of dust of a common instead of an epic. However, its gem rarity will not be updated until Monday (3/30). Invoke cards will now no longer appear from cards that generate other cards. Clever Disguise will now correctly function as intended when played. This coming Monday (3/30), we’re planning to deploy a data-only patch that addresses a couple more issues:
      Darkness Awaits will no longer be incorrectly marked as collectible in the Collection. Basic cards will no longer be incorrectly earned from Arena rewards. Living Root’s gem rarity will be corrected from Epic to Common. There are several known issues that will self-resolve on 4/7 when the Demon Hunter and Ashes of Outland unlock:
      Felfin Navigator will correctly appear in the Battlegrounds minion pool. The Battlegrounds Perks button will correctly function as intended when clicked. The new Priest cards will correctly appear in the Arena card pool. Demon Hunter Initiate cards will no longer be granted by completing Galakrond’s Awakening Chapters. Hallucination and Blink Fox will work correctly when played against Demon Hunter in Practice Mode. Curious Glimmerroot will no longer cause client crashes when played against Demon Hunter in Practice Mode. The Search Bar in the Collection will correctly function as intended, and will no longer jump to the top of the screen. Additionally, there are a few Boomsday Project Puzzles that can no longer be completed now because of card changes introduced in 17.0. We’re planning to deploy a fix for Boomsday Project Puzzles on April 9.
      We are investigating several other reports and will keep you posted as we know more. We’d like to thank everyone for their patience while we get some of these bugs squashed!
    • By Stan
      Update 17.0 came with free decks for returning players. Blizzard defines a returning player as one who had not logged into the game for four months as of March 17, meaning if you logged into Hearthstone between November 18, 2019 and now, you don't qualify as a returning player and won't receive the Class Deck.
      Blizzard (Source)
      As our new Returning Player Experience went live along with the 17.0 update, we’ve found a few places where we think we can clarify the process and what you can expect.
      To expand upon the eligible time period, we’ve defined a returning player as one who had not logged into Hearthstone for four months as of March 17th, so your last login to Hearthstone needed to be before 11/18/2019 to qualify. If you logged in on or between 11/18/2019 to 3/17/2020, you would not qualify as a returning player and receive the Class Deck.
      If you’re a returning player who has not logged in since before 11/18/2019, to earn your free deck
      Log into Hearthstone and be presented with a new Legendary Quest line, which is made up of three total quests. In the first quest, you will face three bosses made specifically for the quest line. In the final two quests, you will play 30 cards then deal 100 damage to an enemy hero. Upon completing the third and final quest, you will be able to select your free Class Deck once you return to the main menu. If you’re a new player and have not completed the new player ranks,
      Log into Hearthstone and complete the tutorial and the Starter Quest line You will need to graduate from the New Player Ranks (Ranks 50-26) Upon completing these quests, you will be able to select your free Class Deck once you return to the main menu. If you have played Hearthstone before, but either did not complete the tutorial or the New Player Ranks, you will need to do both before receiving the free Class Deck. Note that there’s also a chance you’ll see the Returning Player quests and need to complete those as well.
      As a final note, it is possible that you may not see the deck in your deck list if you did not have an open deck slot when you chose your free Class Deck. If this happens, don’t worry! You will still receive all of the cards from that deck. If you would like to delete one of your existing decks, you can then navigate to this page and use our deck list. From here, copy the deck code, and you can then add the deck to your deck list from within Hearthstone.
      We hope this helps to clarify the experience for everyone! In addition, we are going to keep investigating any potential issues with the returning player decks, and we will provide updates as we learn anything new.
      EDIT 1: Quick update: the team has indeed identified an issue that we know is affecting some players. We're currently investigating the steps needed to fix it. I may not have an update again until tomorrow, but I'll let everyone know what to expect as soon as I know more.
    • By Stan
      The 17.0 update is now live on PC with mobile coming later today. It includes Battlegrounds and Hall of Fame updates, the Priest rework, card pack duplication protection, and more.
      Blizzard (Source)
      The Ashes of Outland patch ushers in a host of major updates and new features to kick off the Year of the Phoenix!
      Card Packs Now Have Duplicate Protection Across All Rarities

      Starting today, your card packs are going to be full of the good stuff—new cards! You’ll no longer receive more than two copies of any Common, Rare, or Epic card until you have owned two copies of all cards of that rarity in a set. Crafting a card counts towards acquiring it, and any cards you acquire and later disenchant (whether golden or non-golden) count as well. This means that if you get a card that you don’t want, you can disenchant it and you will not receive it again until you have all cards of that rarity from that set. This improvement even affects card packs you already own, but it won’t affect the overall distribution of rarities in card packs.
      Free Deck for New and Returning Players

      If you’re new to the game—or you’ve been away for a spell—we’d like to help you get right to playing and having fun. Starting today, players new to the game who graduate from the New Player ranks will get a free competitive deck from a class of their choice, built with cards from the Year of the Dragon! This also applies to players who haven't logged into the game in the past four months*.
      *Free deck only available to players who have not logged into Hearthstone in the past 4 months beginning on March 17, 2020. Limit one per account.
      Battlegrounds Updates
      Cobalt Guardian has been removed from the Minion pool. NEW HERO – Illidan Stormrage added to the pool.
      Wingmen [Passive] Start of Combat: Your left and right-most minions attack immediately.
      NEW MINIONS
      Deflect-o-Bot [Mech, Tier 3] 3 Attack, 2 Health.
      Divine Shield Whenever you summon a Mech during combat, gain +1 Attack and Divine Shield.  
      Felfin Navigator [Murloc, Tier 3] 4 Attack, 4 Health.
      Battlecry: Give your other Murlocs +1/+1. Card Changes
      Dr. Boom, Mad Genius Old: Cost 9 mana → New: Cost 7 mana. Giggling Inventor Old: Cost 7 mana → New: Cost 6 mana. Raiding Party Old: Cost 4 mana → New: Cost 3 mana. Reckless Experimenter Old: Deathrattle minions you play cost (3) less, but die at end of turn. (Cost can't be reduced below 1.) → New: Deathrattle minions you play cost (3) less, but die at end of turn. Zephrys the Great—Now Greater Than Ever
      Zephrys the Great has been updated for the changes to the Basic/Classic sets in Year of the Phoenix: Removal of the 5 Neutral and 6 Priest cards sent to the Hall of Fame. Addition of Demon Hunter Basic cards (pending Ashes of Outland launch on April 7), and the 6 new Priest Basic/Classic cards. Improved ordering of simulated attacks to best make use of Rush minions to clear Taunts, in order to maximize potential face damage. This should solve many cases where Zephrys ‘missed lethal’ that involved trading a Rush minion into a Taunt before going face with other minions. Zephrys is now more likely to offer a Freeze card when the opponent has a full board, since it locks the opponent out of being able to play any minions. Fixed a bug where Freeze effects were sometimes offered against already-Frozen enemies. Fixed a bug where SI:7 Infiltrator was offered for next turn over Flare for this turn. Fixed several bugs involving the opponent’s weapon and/or Frozen state, for calculating whether healing should be offered. Fixed a bug where minions whose base cost was higher than 10 (such as Shirvallah, the Tiger) were evaluated as being extremely valuable. Fixed a bug where Windfury was not offered for use on a minion that has already attacked once this turn. Fixed a bug where Crazed Alchemist was offered to destroy your own Doomsayer. Priest Cards Entering Hall of Fame

      Players who own the Classic cards below will be granted the full Arcane Dust refund for each. Players who do not have access to the Wild format will have the two Basic cards removed from their Collection and will be granted a full dust refund for both.
      Classic – Auchenai Soulpriest Classic – Holy Fire Classic – Shadowform Classic – Prophet Velen Basic – Divine Spirit Basic – Northshire Cleric Priest Balance Updates
      Power Word: Shield Old: [Cost 1] Give a minion +2 Health. Draw a card. New: [Cost 0] Give a minion +2 Health. Shadow Word: Death Old: [Cost 3] Destroy a minion with 5 or more Attack. New: [Cost 2] Destroy a minion with 5 or more Attack. Holy Smite Old: [Cost 1] Deal 2 damage. New: [Cost 1] Deal 3 damage to a minion. Holy Nova Old: [Cost 5] Deal 2 damage to all enemies. Restore 2 Health to all friendly characters. New: [Cost 4] Deal 2 damage to all enemy minions. Restore 2 Health to all friendly characters. Shadow Madness Old: [Cost 4] Gain control of an enemy minion with 3 or less Attack until end of turn. New: [Cost 3] Gain control of an enemy minion with 3 or less Attack until end of turn. Temple Enforcer Old: [Cost 6] 6/6 - Give a friendly minion +3 Health. New: [Cost 5] 5/6 Give a friendly minion +3 Health. Thoughtsteal Old: [Cost 3] Copy 2 cards in your opponent's deck and add them to your hand. New: [Cost 2] Copy 2 cards in your opponent's deck and add them to your hand. New Priest Cards
      Players will automatically be granted the two new Basic Priest cards, and the four new Classic Priest cards can be crafted or obtained from Classic card packs.
      Basic - Psychic Conjurer
      [Cost 1] 1 Attack, 1 Health Battlecry: Copy a card in your opponent's deck and add it to your hand. Basic - Power Infusion
      [Cost 4] Give a minion +2/+6. Classic - Kul Tiran Chaplain
      [Cost 2] 2 Attack, 3 Health Battlecry: Give a friendly minion +2 Health. Classic - Scarlet Subjugator
      [Cost 1] 2 Attack, 1 Health Battlecry: Give an enemy minion -2 Attack until your next turn. Classic - Shadow Word: Ruin
      [Cost 4] Destroy all minions with 5 or more Attack. Classic - Natalie Seline
      [Cost 8] 8 Attack, 1 Health Battlecry: Destroy a minion and gain its Health. Neutral Cards Entering Hall of Fame

      You will be able to keep your copies of these card once they move to the Hall of Fame, and you’ll also be granted the full Arcane Dust value for each card (up to the maximum number that can be used in a deck). The dust will be automatically awarded once you log-in after March 26.
      Acolyte of Pain Spellbreaker Mind Control Tech Mountain Giant Leeroy Jenkins Ranked Overhaul - Coming April 1
      Starting with the April 2020 Ranked Season, we're replacing the existing ladder in Ranked Mode with a new league system. The new system features five leagues to conquer—Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum, and Diamond—each made up of 10 ranks. Players start each season at Bronze 10 and climb their way to Bronze 1 before graduating to the Silver league, and on through Gold, Platinum, and Diamond before hitting Legend. Each league will also have rank floors at rank 10 and rank 5, where you cannot go down in rank for losing a match. The New Player ranks will have their own league that runs from ranks 40–1. The Legend ranks will continue to work as they currently do.

      To go from one rank to the next—say, Gold 10 to Gold 9—you will need to gain three Stars. You’ll gain one Star for each match you win and lose a Star for a lost match. At the start of each season, players will be awarded a Star Bonus based on their performance the previous season. This Star Bonus acts as a multiplier on the Stars you earn from each win.
      For example, if you have a Star Bonus of 5x and you win a game, you’ll get five Stars instead of one. If your winning game is a part of a win streak, you’ll get double that: 10 Stars! Upon hitting each ranked floor in your climb, your Star Bonus will be reduced by one. When playing with a Star Bonus you’ll be matched by your matchmaking rating (MMR), meaning you’ll be matched even more precisely with players of your similar skill level when climbing!
      New Ranked Rewards

      We’ve reworked the rewards you earn at the end of each season of Ranked play. Your reward chest can now contain card packs from the latest expansion, Rare cards, and even an Epic card, based on the rank you achieve. Five wins at any rank will also award the seasonal card back immediately, instead of at the end of the season.
      There are also brand-new first-time rewards. These one-time rewards of Classic card packs, Rare cards, and Epic cards will be granted immediately upon hitting a ranked floor for the first time on your account. Hitting Legend for the first time in the new ranked system will grant a random Classic Legendary card!
      Ranking Up To End Of Season Reward First-Time Rewards Legend 1 Latest Expansion Pack 1 Random Classic Legendary Card Diamond 5 1 Random Standard Epic Card 1 Classic Pack Diamond 10 1 Latest Expansion Pack 1 Random Classic Epic Card Platinum 5 2 Random Standard Rare Cards 1 Classic Pack Platinum 10 1 Latest Expansion Pack 1 Random Classic Epic Card Gold 5 2 Random Standard Rare Cards 1 Classic Pack Gold 10 1 Latest Expansion Pack 4 Random Classic Rare Cards Silver 5 2 Random Standard Rare Cards 1 Classic Pack Silver 10 1 Latest Expansion Pack 4 Random Classic Rare Cards Bronze 5 1 Standard Rare Card 1 Classic Pack Demon Hunter Prologue – Coming April 2

      The Year of the Phoenix introduces Hearthstone’s first new class since launch: the Demon Hunter!
      Log in and complete the Demon Hunter prologue starting April 2 to receive all 10 Demon Hunter Basic cards, a 20-card Demon Hunter Initiate set (belonging to the Year of the Dragon for rotation purposes), and a pre-built Demon Hunter deck list—so long as you have an open deck slot. Starting with Ashes of Outland, 15 new Demon Hunter cards will be released with each future expansion in the Year of the Phoenix.
      After the prologue has been completed, the Demon Hunter will officially unlock on April 7!
      Set Rotation, Ashes of Outland, and Demon Hunter - Coming April 7

      With the Year of the Dragon’s end at hand, the time has come for Rastakhan’s Rumble, The Boomsday Project, and The Witchwood to enter Wild and rotate out of Standard. The first new expansion of the Year of the Phoenix, Ashes of Outland, launches worldwide on April 7, bringing with it the Demon Hunter and the menacing Rusted Legion!
      Launch Quest Chain
      To celebrate the launch of the Demon Hunter we’ll be introducing a new quest chain on April 7, where you can earn free card packs from Year of the Dragon expansions and Ashes of Outland! The quests will be initially available on the following dates.
      April 7, 10:00 a.m. PT: Play 25 Cards in Play Mode to earn an Ashes of Outland and Descent of Dragons card pack. April 8, 10:00 a.m. PT: Play 3 Games in Play Mode as Demon Hunter to earn an Ashes of Outland and Saviors of Uldum card pack. April 9, 10:00 a.m. PT: Play 20 Spells in any mode to earn an Ashes of Outland and Rise of Shadows card pack. Arena Rotation

      Starting April 7, the Arena will include cards from the following sets:
      Basic Classic Rise of Shadows Saviors of Uldum Descent of Dragons Galakrond's Awakening Ashes of Outland Demon Hunter Initiate
×
×
  • Create New...